Fassin Yves
Ghent University, Gent, Belgium.
Scientometrics. 2021;126(6):5305-5319. doi: 10.1007/s11192-021-03989-w. Epub 2021 May 7.
The Covid-19 pandemic has been the highest disruptive event in the world recent history. Worldwide academic research on this topic has led to an explosion of scientific literature, never seen before. Bibliometrics provide methods to illustrate this exceptional phenomenon in academic publications. The objective of this paper is to analyze the Covid-19 research from a bibliometric perspective and to study the impact of the publication explosion on bibliometric indicators. The present study shows how an exceptional phenomenon has a disruptive impact on bibliometric indicators, such as the h-index and the Journal Impact Factor. The higher the specialization, the higher the possible impact of a disruptive phenomenon. In applied sciences, more important than the research or the discipline, the specific theme of the research is crucial for citations of articles and for their impact. The salience of the topic, the magnitude of the problem at study and the urgency to find solutions are drivers for citations. The study of the Covid-19 research illustrates the relativity of indicators and the need for context. The present study also confirms the plead for responsible metrics of the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA).
新冠疫情是世界近代史上最具颠覆性的事件。全球范围内关于这一主题的学术研究催生了前所未有的科学文献爆炸式增长。文献计量学提供了方法来阐释学术出版物中的这一特殊现象。本文的目的是从文献计量学角度分析新冠疫情研究,并研究出版物爆炸式增长对文献计量指标的影响。本研究展示了一种特殊现象如何对文献计量指标产生颠覆性影响,如h指数和期刊影响因子。专业化程度越高,颠覆性现象可能产生的影响就越大。在应用科学领域,比研究或学科更重要的是,研究的特定主题对于文章的引用及其影响力至关重要。主题的显著性、所研究问题的规模以及寻找解决方案的紧迫性是文章被引用的驱动因素。对新冠疫情研究的分析说明了指标的相对性以及考虑背景的必要性。本研究还证实了《旧金山研究评估宣言》(DORA)中对负责任的计量指标的呼吁。