West and Central Africa Regional Office, UNICEF, Dakar, Senegal.
Health Systems Strengthening Unit-Health Section, West and Central Africa Regional Office, UNICEF, Dakar, Senegal.
Front Public Health. 2021 Apr 29;9:643079. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.643079. eCollection 2021.
Every year, cholera affects 1.3-4.0 million people worldwide with a particularly high presence in Africa. Based on recent studies, effective targeting interventions in hotspots could eliminate up to 50% of cases in Sub-Saharan Africa. Those interventions include Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH) programs whose influence on cholera control, up to the present, has been poorly quantified. Among the few studies available, D'Mello-Guyett et al. underline how the distribution of hygiene kits is a promising form of intervention for cholera control and that the integration of a WASH intervention at the point of admission of suspected cases is new in cholera control efforts, particularly in outbreaks and complex emergencies. Considering the limited number of studies on Community-Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) and water coverages related to cholera control, the aim of our work is to determine whether these interventions in cholera hotspots (geographic areas vulnerable to disease transmission) have significant impact on cholera transmission. In this study, we consider data collected on 125 villages of the Madarounfa district (Niger) during the 2018 cholera outbreak. Using a hurdle model, our findings show that full access to improved sanitation significantly decreases the likelihood of cholera by 91% ( < 0.0001) compared to villages with no access to sanitation at all. Considering only the villages affected by cholera in the studied area, cholera cases decrease by a factor of 4.3 in those villages where there is partial access to at least quality water sources, while full access to improved water sources decreases the cholera cases by a factor of 6.3 when compared to villages without access to water ( < 0.001). In addition, villages without access to safe water and sanitation are 6.7 times ( < 0.0001) more likely to get cholera. Alternatively, villages with full sanitation and water coverage are 9.1 ( < 0.0001) less likely to get cholera. The findings of our study suggest that significant access to improved water and sanitation at the village level offer a strong barrier against cholera transmission. However, it requires full CLTS coverage of the village to observe a strong impact on cholera, as partial access only has a limited impact.
每年,霍乱在全球范围内影响 130 万至 400 万人,在非洲尤为严重。根据最近的研究,在热点地区实施有效靶向干预措施,可在撒哈拉以南非洲地区减少多达 50%的病例。这些干预措施包括水、环境卫生和个人卫生(WASH)方案,迄今为止,人们对其在霍乱控制方面的影响还没有进行充分的量化。在为数不多的可用研究中,D'Mello-Guyett 等人强调了卫生包的分发是霍乱控制的一种很有前景的干预形式,以及在疑似病例入院时整合 WASH 干预措施是霍乱控制工作中的新举措,特别是在暴发和复杂紧急情况下。考虑到关于社区主导的全面环境卫生和与霍乱控制相关的水覆盖范围的研究数量有限,我们的工作旨在确定在霍乱热点地区(易受疾病传播影响的地理区域)实施这些干预措施是否对霍乱传播有重大影响。在这项研究中,我们考虑了在尼日尔马德拉农法区(Madarounfa district)于 2018 年霍乱暴发期间收集的 125 个村庄的数据。使用障碍模型,我们的研究结果表明,与完全没有卫生设施的村庄相比,完全获得改良卫生设施可使霍乱的可能性降低 91%(<0.0001)。在只考虑研究区域内受霍乱影响的村庄的情况下,在那些至少有部分优质水源的村庄中,霍乱病例减少了 4.3 倍,而在完全获得改良水源的村庄中,霍乱病例减少了 6.3 倍,而与没有水的村庄相比(<0.001)。此外,没有安全用水和卫生设施的村庄发生霍乱的可能性高 6.7 倍(<0.0001)。相反,完全实现卫生设施和用水覆盖的村庄发生霍乱的可能性低 9.1 倍(<0.0001)。本研究结果表明,在村庄一级获得显著的改良水和卫生设施可有效防止霍乱传播。然而,要观察到对霍乱的强大影响,需要全面实施社区主导的环境卫生,因为部分获得只能产生有限的影响。