Division of Systems Engineering, Boston University, Boston, MA, United States of America.
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Boston University, Boston, MA, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2021 May 21;16(5):e0243115. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0243115. eCollection 2021.
Single Particle Tracking (SPT) is a well known class of tools for studying the dynamics of biological macromolecules moving inside living cells. In this paper, we focus on the problem of localization and parameter estimation given a sequence of segmented images. In the standard paradigm, the location of the emitter inside each frame of a sequence of camera images is estimated using, for example, Gaussian fitting (GF), and these locations are linked to provide an estimate of the trajectory. Trajectories are then analyzed by using Mean Square Displacement (MSD) or Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) techniques to determine motion parameters such as diffusion coefficients. However, the problems of localization and parameter estimation are clearly coupled. Motivated by this, we have created an Expectation Maximization (EM) based framework for simultaneous localization and parameter estimation. We demonstrate this framework through two representative methods, namely, Sequential Monte Carlo combined with Expectation Maximization (SMC-EM) and Unscented Kalman Filter combined with Expectation Maximization (U-EM). Using diffusion in two-dimensions as a prototypical example, we conduct quantitative investigations on localization and parameter estimation performance across a wide range of signal to background ratios and diffusion coefficients and compare our methods to the standard techniques based on GF-MSD/MLE. To demonstrate the flexibility of the EM based framework, we do comparisons using two different camera models, an ideal camera with Poisson distributed shot noise but no readout noise, and a camera with both shot noise and the pixel-dependent readout noise that is common to scientific complementary metal-oxide semiconductor (sCMOS) camera. Our results indicate our EM based methods outperform the standard techniques, especially at low signal levels. While U-EM and SMC-EM have similar accuracy, U-EM is significantly more computationally efficient, though the use of the Unscented Kalman Filter limits U-EM to lower diffusion rates.
单颗粒跟踪 (SPT) 是一类用于研究生物大分子在活细胞内运动动力学的知名工具。在本文中,我们专注于给定一系列分割图像的定位和参数估计问题。在标准范例中,使用例如高斯拟合 (GF) 来估计序列中每一帧相机图像内的发射器位置,并且这些位置被链接以提供轨迹的估计。然后使用均方位移 (MSD) 或最大似然估计 (MLE) 技术来分析轨迹,以确定扩散系数等运动参数。然而,定位和参数估计的问题显然是耦合的。受此启发,我们创建了一个基于期望最大化 (EM) 的同时定位和参数估计框架。我们通过两种有代表性的方法来证明这个框架,即,与期望最大化 (SMC-EM) 相结合的序列蒙特卡罗法和与期望最大化 (U-EM) 相结合的无迹卡尔曼滤波法。使用二维扩散作为原型示例,我们在广泛的信号与背景比和扩散系数范围内进行了定位和参数估计性能的定量研究,并将我们的方法与基于 GF-MSD/MLE 的标准技术进行了比较。为了展示基于 EM 的框架的灵活性,我们使用两种不同的相机模型进行了比较,一种是具有泊松分布的散粒噪声但没有读出噪声的理想相机,另一种是具有散粒噪声和像素相关读出噪声的相机,这种噪声常见于科学互补金属氧化物半导体 (sCMOS) 相机。我们的结果表明,我们的基于 EM 的方法优于标准技术,尤其是在低信号水平下。虽然 U-EM 和 SMC-EM 具有相似的准确性,但 U-EM 的计算效率显著更高,尽管使用无迹卡尔曼滤波限制了 U-EM 只能用于较低的扩散率。