Norris Anne E, Thalasinos Roxana Delcampo, Hecht Michael L
REAL Prevention, LLC, Oviedo, FL, United States.
School of Nursing and Health Studies, University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2021 Jun 2;5(6):e24937. doi: 10.2196/24937.
Taking evidence-based interventions to scale is a challenge for prevention science. Mighty Girls is an evidence-based sexual health intervention program that combines classroom sessions with novel, cutting-edge technology (digital puppetry). The program was developed for 7th grade Latinas, but US school and community demographics rarely allow interventions targeting a single ethnic group. Additionally, digital puppetry is costly to scale up, and parent disapproval often prevents successful dissemination of adolescent sexual health programs. Intervening steps along the scaling-up pathway are needed to adapt the program prior to scaling up for dissemination.
The aims of this study were to create a multicultural adaptation of the Mighty Girls program using a mobile app that is less costly to disseminate and is acceptable to parents of 7th grade girls.
This study used a three-phase process to adapt Mighty Girls into Mighty Teens. All phases used purposive (nonprobability) sampling of low-income, multicultural, urban metropolitan groups (7th grade girls and their parents) within central Florida. Phase 1 involved two videotaped implementations of a multicultural adaptation of the classroom sessions, one involving focus groups (N=14) and the other serving as a single-group pretest-posttest pilot study (N=23). Phase 2 involved development of a narrative cell phone app prototype, which was subjected to usability testing (N=25). App usability and engagement were assessed qualitatively (observation, focus group, open-ended questions) and quantitatively. Phase 3 used focus groups to assess parent support for the program (N=6). Qualitative data were analyzed using descriptive content analysis. Quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and paired t tests.
Qualitative findings supported classroom sessions being multicultural, and identified simple changes to improve engagement and learning. Quantitative findings from the second classroom session implementation pilot study indicated a significant pre-post difference in intention to delay sexual intercourse (P=.04). App usability and appeal were supported by a System Usability Scale score of 76 (exceeding 68 per the industry standard) and 83% (20/24) of participants agreeing they would recommend the app to friends. Parents (mothers) expressed only positive regard for program goals, and classroom session and app activities.
This study adapted Mighty Girls into an engaging, easier-to-disseminate, multicultural program, termed Mighty Teens, that uses a narrative-generating app to support behavior change, and is likely to be accepted by parents of 7th grade girls. This study also provides evidence of the preliminary effectiveness of Mighty Teens classroom sessions. The sampling method and sample size were appropriate for adaptation, but research involving a more representative US sample is needed to confirm multicultural fit, parent receptivity, and program effectiveness. Study implications include integrating app use throughout the classroom sessions to build narrative-generating skills across the program and increasing the number of narratives produced, which should in turn increase the program's behavior change potency.
扩大基于证据的干预措施的规模是预防科学面临的一项挑战。“强大女孩”是一项基于证据的性健康干预项目,它将课堂教学与新颖、前沿的技术(数字木偶戏)相结合。该项目是为七年级的拉丁裔女孩开发的,但美国学校和社区的人口统计数据很少允许针对单一族裔群体的干预措施。此外,扩大数字木偶戏的规模成本高昂,家长的反对往往会阻碍青少年性健康项目的成功传播。在扩大规模进行传播之前,需要在扩大规模的过程中采取干预措施来调整该项目。
本研究的目的是使用一款传播成本较低且七年级女孩家长能够接受的移动应用程序,对“强大女孩”项目进行多文化适应性调整。
本研究采用三阶段过程将“强大女孩”调整为“强大青少年”。所有阶段都采用了目的性(非概率)抽样,选取了佛罗里达州中部的低收入、多文化、城市大都市群体(七年级女孩及其家长)。第一阶段包括对课堂教学进行多文化适应性调整的两次录像实施,一次涉及焦点小组(N = 14),另一次作为单组前测 - 后测试点研究(N = 23)。第二阶段涉及开发一个叙事手机应用程序原型,并对其进行可用性测试(N = 25)。通过定性(观察、焦点小组、开放式问题)和定量方式评估应用程序的可用性和参与度。第三阶段使用焦点小组评估家长对该项目的支持度(N = 6)。定性数据采用描述性内容分析进行分析。定量数据采用描述性统计和配对t检验进行分析。
定性研究结果支持课堂教学具有多文化性,并确定了一些简单的改变以提高参与度和学习效果。第二次课堂教学实施试点研究的定量结果表明,在延迟性行为的意图方面,前后存在显著差异(P = 0.04)。系统可用性量表得分为76(超过行业标准的68分),83%(20/24)的参与者表示会向朋友推荐该应用程序,这支持了应用程序的可用性和吸引力。家长(母亲)对项目目标、课堂教学和应用程序活动仅表达了积极的看法。
本研究将“强大女孩”调整为一个引人入胜、易于传播的多文化项目,称为“强大青少年”,该项目使用一个生成叙事的应用程序来支持行为改变,并且很可能会被七年级女孩的家长所接受。本研究还提供了“强大青少年”课堂教学初步有效性的证据。抽样方法和样本量适合进行适应性调整,但需要进行涉及更具代表性的美国样本的研究,以确认多文化适应性、家长接受度和项目有效性。研究意义包括在整个课堂教学中整合应用程序的使用,以在整个项目中培养生成叙事的技能,并增加生成的叙事数量,这反过来应该会增强项目的行为改变效力。