Kirk-Provencher Katelyn T, Spillane Nichea S, Schick Melissa R, Chalmers Sydney J, Hawes Courtney, Orchowski Lindsay M
Department of Psychology, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI, USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Alpert Medical School, Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2023 Jan;24(1):110-124. doi: 10.1177/15248380211021606. Epub 2021 Jun 10.
Sexual and gender minority (SGM) individuals are at increased risk for experiencing sexual violence. Bystander intervention training programs are a first-line prevention recommendation for reducing sexual and dating violence on college campuses. Little is known regarding the extent to which SGM individuals are represented in the content of bystander intervention programs or are included in studies examining the effectiveness of bystander intervention programs. The present critical review aimed to fill this gap in knowledge. Twenty-eight empirical peer-reviewed evaluations of bystander intervention programs aimed at reducing dating violence or sexual assault on college campuses were examined. Three studies (10.7%) described including content representing SGM individuals in the program. Personal communication with study authors indicated that-although not mentioned in the publication-many programs describe rates of violence among SGM students. When describing the study sample, six studies (21.4%) indicated that transgender, nonbinary, or students classified as "other" were included in the research. Approximately two thirds of studies (67.9%) did not describe participants' sexual orientation. No studies reported outcomes specifically among SGM individuals, and two (7.1%) mentioned a lack of SGM inclusion as a study limitation. Work is needed to better represent SGM individuals in the content of bystander intervention programs and ensure adequate representation of SGM individuals in studies examining the effectiveness of bystander intervention programs.
性与性别少数群体(SGM)遭受性暴力的风险更高。旁观者干预培训项目是大学校园减少性暴力和约会暴力的一线预防建议。关于SGM个体在旁观者干预项目内容中的呈现程度,或在检验旁观者干预项目有效性的研究中的纳入情况,人们知之甚少。本综述旨在填补这一知识空白。我们考察了28项针对大学校园减少约会暴力或性侵犯的旁观者干预项目的实证同行评审评估。三项研究(10.7%)描述了在项目中纳入了代表SGM个体的内容。与研究作者的个人交流表明,尽管出版物中未提及,但许多项目描述了SGM学生中的暴力发生率。在描述研究样本时,六项研究(21.4%)表明研究中纳入了跨性别、非二元性别或被归类为“其他”的学生。约三分之二的研究(67.9%)未描述参与者的性取向。没有研究报告SGM个体的具体结果,两项研究(7.1%)提到未纳入SGM个体是研究的一个局限。需要开展工作,以便在旁观者干预项目内容中更好地呈现SGM个体,并确保在检验旁观者干预项目有效性的研究中充分纳入SGM个体。