Department of Anaesthesiology and Pain Medicine, St. Vincent's University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Department of Anaesthesiology and Pain Medicine, Beaumont Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Ir J Med Sci. 2022 Jun;191(3):1315-1323. doi: 10.1007/s11845-021-02673-5. Epub 2021 Jun 10.
Chronic pain management services have historically been under-resourced in Ireland. There is no agreed model of care for chronic pain management services in Ireland. Previous studies have assessed the extent of services in Ireland without examining waiting times for access to services.
This study aimed to quantify the extent of, geographical distribution of and waiting times for access to publicly funded chronic pain management services in Ireland.
Using the British Pain Society's Core Standards for Pain Management Services in the UK (2015) and International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP) recommendations, a questionnaire was devised. Publically funded departments in Ireland were contacted and questionnaires completed. Waiting list data was publicly available and obtained from the National Treatment Purchase Fund website.
There was a 100% response rate. Sixteen publicly funded chronic pain management services were identified. There are 27 chronic pain management consultants (16.6 whole time equivalents (WTE)) practicing chronic pain management, amounting to 0.55 specialists (0.34 WTEs)/100,000 of the population. There are 21 WTE for non-consultant hospital doctors (NCHDs), 26.5 WTEs for nursing, 8 WTEs for physiotherapy and 6.2 WTEs for psychology, nationally. A percentage of 93.75% of departments (n = 15) provide interventional therapies, 37.5% (n = 6) provide advanced neuromodulation and 43.75% (n = 7) are managing intrathecal pump therapies. There are five pain management programmes nationally. As of January 2020, ~ 25% patients on waiting lists for outpatient appointments were waiting > 18 months, with ~ 17% patients on waiting lists for interventional treatments waiting > 12 months.
Shortage of multidisciplinary staff is of particular concern for Irish services. Patient access is limited as evidenced by significant waiting lists. In order to improve access to care and bring services in line with international recommendations, increased resources are needed.
慢性疼痛管理服务在爱尔兰一直资源不足。爱尔兰没有针对慢性疼痛管理服务的既定护理模式。以前的研究评估了爱尔兰服务的范围,但没有检查获得服务的等待时间。
本研究旨在量化爱尔兰公共资助的慢性疼痛管理服务的范围、地理分布和获得服务的等待时间。
使用英国疼痛学会的英国疼痛管理服务核心标准(2015 年)和国际疼痛研究协会(IASP)的建议,设计了一份问卷。联系了爱尔兰的公共资助部门,并完成了问卷。等待名单数据是公开的,并从国家治疗购买基金网站获得。
回应率为 100%。确定了 16 个公共资助的慢性疼痛管理服务。有 27 名慢性疼痛管理顾问(16.6 个全职等效(WTE))从事慢性疼痛管理工作,相当于每 10 万人中有 0.55 名专家(0.34 WTEs)。全国有 21 个 WTE 用于非顾问医院医生(NCHD),26.5 WTE 用于护理,8 WTE 用于物理治疗和 6.2 WTE 用于心理学。93.75%的部门(n=15)提供介入治疗,37.5%(n=6)提供高级神经调节,43.75%(n=7)管理鞘内泵治疗。全国有 5 个疼痛管理项目。截至 2020 年 1 月,门诊预约等候名单上约 25%的患者等待时间超过 18 个月,约 17%的介入治疗等候名单上的患者等待时间超过 12 个月。
多学科工作人员短缺是爱尔兰服务的特别关注点。患者获得服务的机会有限,这表明等候名单很长。为了改善获得护理的机会,并使服务符合国际建议,需要增加资源。