Shaikh Summaiya Zareen, Tejashree Dabholkar, Ajit Dabholkar
School of Physiotherapy, D.Y. Patil University, Navi Mumbai, 400706, India.
J Med Ultrason (2001). 2021 Jul;48(3):285-294. doi: 10.1007/s10396-021-01104-3. Epub 2021 Jun 11.
Optimising ultrasonography imaging (UI) applications for clients is a highly specific and sensitive add-on method. The aim of this meta-analysis was to systematically evaluate the clinical utilisation of UI in musculoskeletal conditions by rehabilitation providers in the past decade. Two reviewers independently assessed relevant research articles from five databases electronically (Medline, Cochrane Library, EMBASE, ProQuest, EBSCO) and screened titles and abstracts based on predefined eligibility criteria (2010- 2020). A total of 147 articles were screened for eligibility by two reviewers independently, and any disagreements were resolved by another reviewer using Rayyan QCRI software. Ninety-seven duplicates were removed, and after excluding 21 studies, 16 randomized controlled trials were included and full texts retrieved. Data were synthesised using Revman 5.4 software for qualitative analysis and risk-of-bias assessment. Four similar studies were statistically analysed for heterogeneity of abdominal muscle contraction ratios. Two interventional studies were also analysed to assess the effect of feedback. The diagnostic application of UI was investigated using a consistent amount of literature, though from a rehabilitation perspective the literature is inconclusive. The clinical utility of UI in rehabilitation by physical therapists is conclusive and has potential to advance clinical practice. Further well-designed randomized controlled trials minimising selection biases will help improve the quality in this domain. Critical reflection, clinical reasoning, and mutual goal setting will help practising physical therapists to scrutinize the clinical practice more objectively.
为客户优化超声成像(UI)应用是一种高度特定且敏感的附加方法。本荟萃分析的目的是系统评估过去十年康复治疗师在肌肉骨骼疾病中对UI的临床应用情况。两名评审员独立地通过电子方式从五个数据库(Medline、Cochrane图书馆、EMBASE、ProQuest、EBSCO)评估相关研究文章,并根据预定义的纳入标准(2010 - 2020年)筛选标题和摘要。两名评审员独立筛选了总共147篇文章的纳入资格,任何分歧由另一名评审员使用Rayyan QCRI软件解决。去除了97篇重复文章,在排除21项研究后,纳入了16项随机对照试验并检索了全文。使用Revman 5.4软件进行数据合成以进行定性分析和偏倚风险评估。对四项类似研究进行了腹肌收缩率异质性的统计分析。还分析了两项干预性研究以评估反馈的效果。尽管从康复角度来看文献尚无定论,但对UI的诊断应用进行了一定数量文献的研究。物理治疗师在康复中使用UI的临床效用是确定的,并且有推进临床实践的潜力。进一步设计良好且尽量减少选择偏倚的随机对照试验将有助于提高该领域的质量。批判性反思、临床推理和共同目标设定将有助于执业物理治疗师更客观地审视临床实践。