Ford Tabitha R, Fix Megan L, Shappell Eric, Egan Daniel J, Mannix Alexandra, Bailitz John, Li Xian, Gottlieb Michael
Division of Emergency Medicine University of Vermont Medical Center Burlington VT USA.
Division of Emergency Medicine University of Utah School of Medicine Salt Lake City UT USA.
AEM Educ Train. 2021 Jan 28;5(3):e10568. doi: 10.1002/aet2.10568. eCollection 2021 Jul.
In December 2019, a novel coronavirus (COVID-19) caused widespread clinical disease, triggering limited in-person gatherings and social-distancing guidelines to minimize transmission. These regulations led most emergency medicine (EM) residency training programs to rapidly transition to virtual didactics. We sought to evaluate EM resident perceptions of the effects of COVID-19 on their didactic and clinical education.
We performed a cross-sectional survey study at seven EM residency programs using a mixed-methods approach designed to understand resident perceptions regarding the impact of COVID-19 on their educational experience. Quantitative data were presented as percentages with comparison of subgroups, while open-ended responses were analyzed using qualitative methodology.
We achieved a 59% response rate (187/313). The majority of respondents (119/182, 65.4%) reported that the COVID-19 pandemic had a negative impact on their residency education with junior residents disproportionately affected. A total of 81 of 182 (44.5%) participants reported that one or more of their clinical rotations were partially or completely canceled due to the pandemic. Additionally, we identified four themes and 34 subthemes highlighting the contextual effects of the pandemic, which were then divided into positive and negative influences on the residency experience. The four themes include systems experience, clinical experience, didactic experience, and wellness.
Our study examined the impact of COVID-19 on residents' educational experiences. We found overall mixed responses with a slightly negative impact on residency education, wellness, and clinical rotations, while satisfaction with EM as a career choice was increased. Factors influencing this included systems, clinical, and didactic experiences as well as overall wellness.
2019年12月,一种新型冠状病毒(COVID-19)引发了广泛的临床疾病,促使人们减少面对面聚会并实施社交距离准则以尽量减少传播。这些规定导致大多数急诊医学(EM)住院医师培训项目迅速转向虚拟教学。我们旨在评估急诊医学住院医师对COVID-19对其教学和临床教育影响的看法。
我们在七个急诊医学住院医师培训项目中进行了一项横断面调查研究,采用混合方法来了解住院医师对COVID-19对其教育经历影响的看法。定量数据以百分比形式呈现并进行亚组比较,而开放式回答则采用定性方法进行分析。
我们的回复率为59%(187/313)。大多数受访者(119/182,65.4%)报告称,COVID-19大流行对他们的住院医师培训教育产生了负面影响,初级住院医师受到的影响尤为严重。在182名参与者中,共有81人(44.5%)报告称,由于大流行,他们的一个或多个临床轮转被部分或完全取消。此外,我们确定了四个主题和34个子主题,突出了大流行的背景影响,然后将其分为对住院医师培训经历的积极和消极影响。这四个主题包括系统体验、临床体验、教学体验和健康状况。
我们的研究考察了COVID-19对住院医师教育经历的影响。我们发现总体反应不一,对住院医师培训教育、健康状况和临床轮转有轻微负面影响,而对将急诊医学作为职业选择的满意度有所提高。影响这一情况的因素包括系统、临床和教学体验以及整体健康状况。