Lincoln Medical and Mental Health Center, Department of Pediatrics and Emergency Medicine, Bronx, New York.
Weill Cornell Medicine, Department of Pediatric Emergency Medicine, New York, New York.
West J Emerg Med. 2022 Jan 18;23(2):246-250. doi: 10.5811/westjem.2021.10.54266.
The 2019 novel coronavirus pandemic has caused significant disruptions in the clinical operations of hospitals as well as clinical education, training, and research at academic centers. New York State was among the first and largest epicenters of the pandemic, resulting in significant disruptions across its 29 emergency medicine (EM) residency programs. We conducted a cross-sectional observational study of EM residency programs in New York State to assess the impact of the pandemic on resident education and training programs.
We surveyed a cross-sectional sample of residency programs throughout New York State in June 2020, in the timeframe immediately after the state's first "wave" of the pandemic. The survey was distributed to program leadership and elicited information on pandemic-prompted curricular modifications and other educational changes. The survey covered topics related to disruptions in medical education and sought details on solutions to educational issues encountered by programs.
Of the 29 accredited EM residency programs in New York State, leadership from 22 (76%) responded. Of these participating programs, 11 (50%) experienced high pandemic impact on clinical services, 21 (95%) canceled their own trainees' off-service rotations, 22 (100%) canceled or postponed visiting medical student rotations, 22 (100%) adopted virtual conference formats (most within the first week of the pandemic wave), and 11 (50%) stopped all prospective research (excluding COVID-19 research), while most programs continued retrospective research.
This study highlights the profound educational impact of the pandemic on residency programs in one of the hardest- and earliest-hit regions in the United States. Specifically, it highlights the ubiquity of virtual conferencing, the significant impact on research, and the concerns about canceled rotations and missed training opportunities for residents, as well as prehospital and non-physician practitioner trainees. This data should be used to prompt discussion regarding the necessity of alternate educational modalities for pandemic times and the sequelae of implementing these plans.
2019 年新型冠状病毒大流行导致医院的临床运营以及学术中心的临床教育、培训和研究受到重大干扰。纽约州是大流行的首批和最大的中心之一,其 29 个急诊医学(EM)住院医师培训计划受到了重大干扰。我们对纽约州的 EM 住院医师培训计划进行了横断面观察性研究,以评估大流行对住院医师教育和培训计划的影响。
我们在 2020 年 6 月对纽约州的住院医师培训计划进行了横断面抽样调查,时间正好在该州大流行的第一波之后。该调查分发给项目领导层,并征集了与大流行引发的课程修改和其他教育变化有关的信息。该调查涵盖了与医学教育中断有关的主题,并寻求了有关项目遇到的教育问题的解决方案。
在纽约州的 29 个认可的急诊医学住院医师培训计划中,有 22 个(76%)的领导层做出了回应。在参与的这些计划中,有 11 个(50%)的临床服务受到大流行的高度影响,21 个(95%)取消了自己受训人员的非专业轮转,22 个(100%)取消或推迟了来访医学生轮转,22 个(100%)采用了虚拟会议形式(大多数在大流行波的第一周内),11 个(50%)停止了所有前瞻性研究(不包括 COVID-19 研究),而大多数计划继续进行回顾性研究。
本研究强调了大流行对美国受灾最严重和最早受灾地区之一的住院医师培训计划的深远教育影响。具体来说,它强调了虚拟会议的普遍性、对研究的重大影响,以及对住院医师、院前和非医师从业者受训者取消轮转和错过培训机会的担忧。这些数据应被用于引发有关大流行时期替代教育模式的必要性以及实施这些计划的后果的讨论。