School of Allied Health, Curtin University, Perth, Australia.
Telethon Kids Institute, Perth, Australia.
Ergonomics. 2021 Dec;64(12):1606-1622. doi: 10.1080/00140139.2021.1948617. Epub 2021 Jul 26.
Mobile touch screen devices (smartphones and tablet computers) have become an integral part of many parents' and children's lives, with this interaction linked to physical, mental and social outcomes. Despite the known importance of parent-child attachment, evidence on the association between device use and attachment was yet to be reviewed. Following protocol pre-registration, databases were searched, papers screened, and methodological quality assessed. Three papers met the inclusion criteria, and reported some negative associations between duration of parent/child smartphone use and attachment outcomes. A narrative synthesis on two groups of related papers found child time using any screen technology (including television viewing), and child 'problematic' internet, mobile phone, gaming and social media use, was negatively associated with attachment outcomes. Currently there is limited direct evidence on any association between time parents or children spend using these devices and parent-child attachment to support time guidelines for families and professionals working with families. Many parents and children regularly spend time using smartphones and tablet computers. This systematic review found limited evidence evaluating associations between child/adolescent or parent time using devices and parent-child attachment. Until quality evidence exists, practitioners should be alert to potential impacts of device use on family relationships and child outcomes.
移动触屏设备(智能手机和平板电脑)已成为许多家长和孩子生活不可或缺的一部分,这种互动与身体、心理和社会结果有关。尽管众所周知父母与子女的依恋关系很重要,但有关设备使用与依恋关系之间的关联的证据尚待审查。根据预先注册的方案,对数据库进行了搜索,筛选了论文,并评估了方法学质量。有三篇论文符合纳入标准,并报告了父母/子女使用智能手机的时间与依恋结果之间存在一些负面关联。对两组相关论文的叙述性综合分析发现,儿童使用任何屏幕技术(包括看电视)的时间,以及儿童“问题性”上网、手机、游戏和社交媒体的使用,与依恋结果呈负相关。目前,关于父母或子女使用这些设备的时间与亲子依恋之间的任何关联的直接证据有限,无法为家庭和与家庭合作的专业人员提供时间指导。许多家长和孩子经常花时间使用智能手机和平板电脑。这项系统评价发现,评估儿童/青少年或父母使用设备的时间与亲子依恋之间关联的证据有限。在有高质量证据之前,从业者应警惕设备使用对家庭关系和儿童结果的潜在影响。