Kiang Wu Nursing College of Macau, Est. Repouso No. 35, R/C, Macao, SAR, PR China.
Nursing Studies, School of Health in Social Science, Teviot Place, the University of Edinburgh, Room 2M3, Doorway 6, Edinburgh, EH8 9AG, UK.
BMC Palliat Care. 2021 Jul 9;20(1):105. doi: 10.1186/s12904-021-00807-1.
The modern hospice movement is often recognised as a social movement. However, such understanding is primarily based on historic reflection and this approach has lacked theoretical exploration. There is a lack of systematic examination of the modern hospice movement by way of social movement theories.
Focusing on the Chinese socio-cultural context of Macao, this study aimed to understand the EoLC movement by applying the social movement theory, the Framing Perspective, as proposed by Snow and Benford in 1988.
A case study approach was conducted. Semi-structured interviews were held between 2012 and 2013, with pioneers (n = 11) of the EoLC in Macao. Thematic analysis was adopted to analyse the interviews.
The Framing Perspective analysis illuminated that there was both growth and stagnation of the EoLC movement. Three themes emerged: 1) the suffering of people at the end of their lives was considered as a social problem needed to be addressed urgently, 2) the incoherent EoLC strategies developed by pioneers indicated the lack of internal ideological cohesion within the movement, 3) external constraints contributed to the stagnation of the movement.
The EoLC development in Macao can be understood as a social movement. The Framing Perspective provided a theoretical way to understand the emergence of EoLC; offering a novel perspective to conceptualise the modern hospice movement. This sociological and theoretical lens opened up new ways for future research to study the emergence of EoLC in different socio-cultural contexts.
现代临终关怀运动通常被认为是一场社会运动。然而,这种理解主要基于历史反思,缺乏理论探索。缺乏通过社会运动理论系统地考察现代临终关怀运动。
本研究聚焦于中国澳门的社会文化背景,旨在通过应用社会运动理论——1988 年 Snow 和 Benford 提出的“框架视角”,来理解澳门的善终服务运动。
采用案例研究方法。2012 年至 2013 年间,对澳门善终服务的先驱者(n=11)进行了半结构化访谈。采用主题分析法对访谈进行分析。
框架视角分析表明,善终服务运动既有增长也有停滞。出现了三个主题:1)生命末期的人所遭受的痛苦被认为是一个亟待解决的社会问题;2)先驱者制定的不协调的善终服务策略表明运动内部缺乏思想凝聚力;3)外部限制导致运动停滞。
澳门善终服务的发展可以被理解为一场社会运动。框架视角为理解善终服务的出现提供了一种理论途径;为概念化现代临终关怀运动提供了一个新视角。这种社会学和理论视角为未来在不同社会文化背景下研究善终服务的出现开辟了新的途径。