Fangmeier Troy L, Stanley Scott M, Knopp Kayla, Rhoades Galena K
University of Denver.
Veterans Administration, San Diego Healthcare System.
Couple Family Psychol. 2020 Sep;9(3):167-180. doi: 10.1037/cfp0000141. Epub 2020 Jun 25.
Although there are studies on voting similarity in mate selection, very little research has examined party identification and relationship quality. We assessed associations between reports of personal and partner voting behavior (Democrat, Republican, or Independent) and both relationship adjustment and commitment to one's partner. We used a national (U.S.) sample of individuals ( = 510) in their 20s and 30s who were mostly in different-sex, serious relationships ( duration = 5.25 years; 50% married). Controlling for age, college graduation, income, religiosity, minority status, and duration of relationship, voting Republican was associated with higher levels of commitment compared to voting Democrat. Similarly, being partnered with someone voting Republican was associated with higher relationship adjustment and commitment compared to being partnered with someone voting Democrat. Notably, differences in commitment were found only among those who were not already married or engaged. Findings were largely consistent with numerous online reports of survey data that have shown modestly greater relationship quality among those who report being politically conservative. While research has shown that people are less attracted to those who vote differently and that voting differently can be associated with lower relationship quality, we did not generally find perceived voting similarity to be associated with relationship adjustment or commitment. There was one exception: In exploratory analyses, Republicans paired with Democrats tended to report substantially lower relationship adjustment than if paired with Republicans. Implications for political differences among intimate partners and clinical work around these themes are discussed.
虽然有关于择偶中投票相似性的研究,但很少有研究考察党派认同与关系质量之间的联系。我们评估了个人及伴侣投票行为(民主党、共和党或无党派)报告与关系调适及对伴侣的承诺之间的关联。我们使用了一个来自美国全国的样本,样本中的个体年龄在二十多岁和三十多岁,大多处于异性的稳定恋爱关系中(恋爱时长为5.25年;50%已婚)。在控制了年龄、大学毕业情况、收入、宗教信仰、少数族裔身份以及恋爱时长后,与投票给民主党相比,投票给共和党与更高水平的承诺相关。同样,与投票给民主党的伴侣在一起相比,与投票给共和党的伴侣在一起与更高的关系调适及承诺相关。值得注意的是,承诺方面的差异仅在那些尚未结婚或订婚的人当中被发现。研究结果在很大程度上与众多在线调查数据报告一致,这些报告显示,在那些自称政治上保守的人当中,关系质量略高。虽然研究表明人们对投票不同的人吸引力较低,且投票不同可能与较低的关系质量相关,但我们总体上并未发现感知到的投票相似性与关系调适或承诺有关联。有一个例外:在探索性分析中,与共和党人配对的共和党人与民主党人配对相比,往往报告关系调适水平要低得多。本文还讨论了亲密伴侣间政治差异的影响以及围绕这些主题的临床工作。