Arima Kazuyo, Shimamura Tamae, Ito Mikiko
Faculty of Nursing, Taisei Gakuin University.
House of Medical Corporation Youseiin Kiyokawa Hospital.
Nihon Koshu Eisei Zasshi. 2021 Sep 7;68(9):608-617. doi: 10.11236/jph.20-121. Epub 2021 Jul 15.
Objectives By targeting the public health nurses (PHNs) who are expected to be actively involved in the implementation of community DOTS practices, we evaluated the quality of the regional DOTS practices based on the three aspects of "enhancing tuberculosis (TB) treatment adherence," "patient-centered support other than treatment," and "coordination with related organizations." We examined the individual and organizational factors that affect the quality of these practices. Further, we clarified the challenges related to the abilities of PHNs.Methods A self-report questionnaire survey of 958 PHNs from local governments with a TB incidence rate of 15 or more was administered in 2015. This resulted in there being 410 valid responses with a valid response rate of 42.8%. The quality of the community DOTS practices was evaluated based on the three aspects by reviewing the literature on expert PHNs for TB patient support. After a preliminary survey, each was evaluated based on a scale of 10 points. A multiple regression analysis was conducted to understand the relationship between these and the TB control implementation system (organizational factors), the experience and motivation of PHNs to support tuberculosis patients, and the learning situation (individual factors).Results The quality of the community DOTS practices was 7.54±1.69 for "enhancing TB treatment adherence," was 6.91±1.63 for "coordination with related organizations," and was 6.68±1.53 for "patient-centered support." The scores for the first factor were higher than those for the latter two factors (P<0.05). With regard to "patient-centered support," one-fourth of the surveyed PHNs rated their practices as low. Each predictor showed a strong relationship with the quality of community DOTS practices, especially "coordination with related organizations" and "patient-centered support" (r=0.787). The significant organizational factors associated with the quality of the community DOTS practices in terms of each aspect were "making an individual support plan for TB patients" (β=0.112-0.270), "reporting own practices at the DOTS conference as a responsible PHN" (β=0.113-0.173), "attending cohort study meetings" (β=0.129-0.167), and the individual factor of "many years of experience as a PHN" (β=0.210-0.316). Additionally, in the model of "coordination with related organizations," "reading specialized books and journals" (β=0.108) was found to be significant and positively related.Conclusion To improve the quality of the community DOTS practices based on the self-evaluation of PHNs, "patient-centered support" with a low score and high relevance to other aspects is a priority. It was also suggested that it would be useful if the PHNs participated in DOTS evaluations, developed individual patient support plans, presented support plans, and participated in performance evaluations to improve the quality of DOTS practices.
目标 通过针对预期积极参与社区直接督导下的短程化疗(DOTS)实践实施的公共卫生护士(PHN),我们从“提高结核病(TB)治疗依从性”、“治疗以外的以患者为中心的支持”和“与相关组织的协调”这三个方面评估了区域DOTS实践的质量。我们研究了影响这些实践质量的个人和组织因素。此外,我们阐明了与公共卫生护士能力相关的挑战。
方法 2015年对来自结核病发病率为15或更高的地方政府的958名公共卫生护士进行了自填式问卷调查。共获得410份有效回复,有效回复率为42.8%。 通过查阅关于结核病患者支持方面的专家公共卫生护士的文献,从上述三个方面评估社区DOTS实践的质量。经过初步调查,每项均根据10分制进行评估。进行多元回归分析以了解这些因素与结核病控制实施系统(组织因素)、公共卫生护士支持结核病患者的经验和动机以及学习情况(个人因素)之间的关系。
结果 “提高结核病治疗依从性”方面的社区DOTS实践质量为7.54±1.69,“与相关组织的协调”方面为6.91±1.63,“以患者为中心的支持”方面为6.68±1.53。第一个因素的得分高于后两个因素(P<0.05)。在“以患者为中心的支持”方面,四分之一的受访公共卫生护士将他们的实践评为低分。每个预测因素都与社区DOTS实践的质量显示出很强的关系,尤其是“与相关组织的协调”和“以患者为中心的支持”(r = 0.787)。在各个方面,与社区DOTS实践质量相关的重要组织因素包括“为结核病患者制定个人支持计划”(β = 0.从0.112到0.270)、“作为负责的公共卫生护士在DOTS会议上汇报自己的实践”(β = 0.113至0.173)、“参加队列研究会议”(β = 0.129至0.167)以及“公共卫生护士多年的经验”这一个人因素(β = 0.210至0.316)。此外,在“与相关组织的协调”模型中,“阅读专业书籍和期刊”(β = 0.108)被发现具有显著性且呈正相关。
结论 为了基于公共卫生护士的自我评价提高社区DOTS实践的质量,得分较低且与其他方面高度相关的“以患者为中心的支持”是优先事项。还建议公共卫生护士参与DOTS评估、制定个人患者支持计划、展示支持计划并参与绩效评估,以提高DOTS实践的质量。