MIVEGEC, Univ. Montpellier, CNRS, IRD, Montpellier, France.
Centre Emile Durkheim, CNRS, Bordeaux, France.
J Evol Biol. 2021 Dec;34(12):1855-1866. doi: 10.1111/jeb.13904. Epub 2021 Jul 30.
The increase in frequency of multidrug-resistant bacteria worldwide is largely the result of the massive use of antibiotics in the second half of the 20th century. These relatively recent changes in human societies revealed the great evolutionary capacities of bacteria towards drug resistance. In this article, we hypothesize that the success of future antibacterial strategies lies in taking into account both these evolutionary processes and the way human activities influence them. Faced with the increasing prevalence of multidrug-resistant bacteria and the scarcity of new antibacterial chemical molecules, the use of bacteriophages is considered as a complementary and/or alternative therapy. After presenting the evolutionary capacities of bacteriophages and bacteria, we show how the development model currently envisaged (based on the classification of bacteriophages as medicinal products similar to antibacterial chemical molecules) ignores the evolutionary processes inherent in bacteriophage therapy. This categorization imposes to bacteriophage therapy a specific conception of what a treatment and a therapeutic scheme should be as well as its mode of production and prescription. We argue that a new development model is needed that would allow the use of therapeutic bacteriophages fully adapted (after in vitro 'bacteriophage training') to the aetiologic bacteria and/or aimed at rendering bacteria either avirulent or antibiotic-susceptible ('bacteriophage steering'). To not repeat the mistakes made with antibiotics, we must now think about and learn from the ways in which the materialities of microbes (e.g. evolutionary capacities of both bacteriophages and bacteria) are intertwined with those of societies.
全球多药耐药菌的频率增加在很大程度上是由于 20 世纪后半叶抗生素的大量使用。人类社会最近发生的这些变化揭示了细菌对耐药性的巨大进化能力。在本文中,我们假设未来抗菌策略的成功在于既要考虑这些进化过程,又要考虑人类活动对它们的影响。面对多药耐药菌日益增多和新的抗菌化学分子稀缺的局面,噬菌体被认为是一种补充和/或替代疗法。在介绍了噬菌体和细菌的进化能力之后,我们展示了当前设想的开发模式(基于将噬菌体分类为类似于抗菌化学分子的药物)如何忽略了噬菌体治疗中固有的进化过程。这种分类对噬菌体治疗施加了一种特定的概念,即什么是治疗和治疗方案,以及它的生产和处方模式。我们认为,需要一种新的发展模式,允许使用经过体外“噬菌体训练”充分适应病因细菌的治疗性噬菌体,或者旨在使细菌变得无毒或对抗生素敏感(“噬菌体导向”)。为了不再重复使用抗生素时犯的错误,我们现在必须思考并从微生物的物质性(例如噬菌体和细菌的进化能力)与社会的物质性交织在一起的方式中学习。