Health Innovation Center, The MITRE Corporation, McLean, Virginia, USA.
J Health Commun. 2021 Jul 3;26(7):443-459. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2021.1955050. Epub 2021 Aug 4.
This research aims to understand the persuasion techniques used in Twitter posts about COVID-19 vaccines by the different vaccine sentiments (i.e., Pro-Vaccine, Anti-Vaccine, and Neutral) using the Elaboration Likelihood Model, Social judgment Theory, and the Extended Parallel Process Model as theoretical frameworks. A content analysis was conducted on a data set of 1,000 Twitter posts. The corpus of Tweets was examined using the persuasion frameworks; tweets that were identified as emanating from bots were further examined. Results found Anti-Vaccine messages predominantly used Anecdotal stories, Humor/Sarcasm, and Celebrity figures as persuasion techniques, while Pro-Vaccine messages primarily used Information, Celebrity figures, and Participation. Results also showed the Anti-Vaccine messages primarily focused on values related to the categories of Safety, Political/Conspiracy Theories, and Choice. Finally, results revealed Anti-Vaccine messages primarily used Perceived Severity and Perceived Susceptibility, which are fear appeal elements. The findings for messages by bots were comparable to the messages in the larger corpus of tweets. Based on the findings, a response framework-Health Information Persuasion Exploration (HIPE)-is proposed to address mis/disinformation and Anti-Vaccine messaging. The results of this study and the HIPE framework can inform a national COVID-19 vaccine health campaign to increase vaccine adoption.
本研究旨在使用详尽可能性模型、社会判断理论和扩展平行过程模型作为理论框架,了解具有不同疫苗态度(即支持疫苗、反对疫苗和中立)的 Twitter 帖子中关于 COVID-19 疫苗的说服技巧。对 1000 条 Twitter 帖子的数据集进行了内容分析。使用说服框架检查了推文语料库;进一步检查了被确定为源自机器人的推文。研究结果发现,反疫苗信息主要使用轶事故事、幽默/讽刺和名人作为说服技巧,而支持疫苗的信息主要使用信息、名人以及参与度。结果还表明,反疫苗信息主要侧重于与安全、政治/阴谋论和选择相关类别的价值观。最后,研究结果表明,反疫苗信息主要使用感知严重性和感知易感性,这是恐惧诉求的要素。机器人消息的结果与更大的推文语料库中的消息相似。基于这些发现,提出了一个应对框架——健康信息说服探索(HIPE)——以解决错误/虚假信息和反疫苗信息。本研究的结果和 HIPE 框架可以为全国 COVID-19 疫苗健康运动提供信息,以提高疫苗接种率。