Department of Sociology and Criminology, Pennsylvania State University, 412 Oswald Tower, University Park, 16802, Pennsylvania, United States.
Soc Sci Med. 2021 Sep;285:114290. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114290. Epub 2021 Jul 31.
The "Hispanic paradox" refers to the accepted finding that Mexican immigrants have lower mortality compared to the US-born population, despite having lower levels of income, educational attainment, and health insurance coverage. However, Mexican immigrants' mortality advantage is not matched by lower disability rates, particularly later in the life course. Past studies have identified a crossover in disability rates for Mexican immigrants using age-specific disability rates but confound the effects of aging and duration of residence. By using the synthetic cohort method, I extend prior work on the disability crossover by tracing immigrant cohorts across the life course and disentangling newly arrived immigrants from those already established in the U.S. I use American Community Survey (ACS) 2015-2019 data to test whether the acculturation or cumulative disadvantage hypotheses account for the disability crossover. I find that, contrary to the expected finding of a socioeconomic health gradient in disability rates, Mexican immigrants' high disability rates converge regardless of education level or immigrant cohort. In addition, Mexican female immigrants are doubly disadvantaged, living in a protracted period of disability compared to males of the same education level. My findings support the negative health acculturation hypothesis as the dominant pathway for Mexican immigrants' later-life disability trajectories and consequently the explanation behind the disability crossover.
“西班牙裔悖论”是指一个公认的发现,即与美国出生的人口相比,墨西哥移民的死亡率较低,尽管他们的收入、教育程度和医疗保险覆盖率较低。然而,墨西哥移民的死亡率优势并没有转化为较低的残疾率,特别是在生命后期。过去的研究已经通过特定年龄段的残疾率来确定墨西哥移民的残疾率交叉点,但这混淆了老龄化和居住时间的影响。通过使用合成队列方法,我通过跟踪移民队列在整个生命过程中的轨迹,并将新移民与已经在美国定居的移民区分开来,扩展了关于残疾交叉点的先前工作。我使用 2015-2019 年美国社区调查(ACS)数据来检验文化适应或累积劣势假设是否可以解释残疾交叉点。我发现,与残疾率的社会经济健康梯度的预期发现相反,墨西哥移民的高残疾率无论教育程度或移民队列如何都在趋同。此外,墨西哥女性移民处于双重劣势地位,与同教育水平的男性相比,她们处于长期残疾期。我的研究结果支持负面的文化适应假设,即墨西哥移民晚年残疾轨迹的主要途径,也是残疾交叉点背后的解释。