Min Jihee, Kim Jee Ye, Yeon Sujin, Ryu Jiin, Min Jin Joo, Park Seho, Kim Seung Il, Jeon Justin Y
Department of Physiology, Yonsei Institute of Sports Science & Exercise Medicine, Yonsei University Wonju College of Medicine, Wonju 26426, Korea.
Exercise Medicine and Rehabilitation Laboratory, Department of Sport Industry Studies, Yonsei University, Seoul 03722, Korea.
J Clin Med. 2021 Jul 31;10(15):3416. doi: 10.3390/jcm10153416.
Breast cancer surgery significantly affects the shoulder's range of motion (ROM) and strength. However, the extent of shoulder impairment, as well as patterns of recovery immediately after surgery, is not fully understood. Therefore, we aimed to investigate shoulder ROM and strength during the early recovery phase after surgery. Thirty-two breast cancer patients were observed five times: the day before surgery, discharge day (postoperative day 1 (POD1) or (POD2)), first outpatient visit (POD7-10), second outpatient visit (POD14-20), and third outpatient visit (POD21-30). We assessed shoulder passive ROM and strength for both affected and unaffected arms at each observation. ROM decreased in both affected and unaffected sides post-surgery. ROM on the affected side did not recover to the pre-surgery level until the third outpatient visit (POD24). In contrast, the ROM on the unaffected side recovered to the pre-surgery level by the first outpatient visit (POD10). The shoulder strength of both arms declined and did not recover to pre-surgery levels. Shoulder strength in the affected arm significantly decreased immediately after surgery (52.9% of the pre-surgery levels) and did not recover until the third outpatient visit (62.5% of the pre-surgery levels), whereas that in the unaffected arm decreased gradually (83.1 ± 2.3 at POD 1 and 78.9 ± 2.9 at POD 24). Descriptively, patterns of recovery in ROM may vary according to types of surgery while patterns of recovery in shoulder strength did not: shoulder strength significantly decreased and did not recover notably regardless of types of surgery. Both shoulder ROM and strength reduced during the early recovery phase after breast cancer surgery regardless of types of surgery, although the degree of reduction was greater in shoulder strength than ROM. Our findings suggest that rehabilitation exercises should be implemented in both upper limbs.
乳腺癌手术会显著影响肩部的活动范围(ROM)和力量。然而,肩部损伤的程度以及术后即刻的恢复模式尚未完全明确。因此,我们旨在研究术后早期恢复阶段的肩部ROM和力量。对32例乳腺癌患者进行了5次观察:手术前一天、出院日(术后第1天(POD1)或第2天(POD2))、首次门诊就诊(POD7 - 10)、第二次门诊就诊(POD14 - 20)以及第三次门诊就诊(POD21 - 30)。每次观察时,我们都评估了患侧和健侧手臂的肩部被动ROM和力量。术后患侧和健侧的ROM均下降。患侧的ROM直到第三次门诊就诊(POD24)才恢复到术前水平。相比之下,健侧的ROM在首次门诊就诊(POD10)时就恢复到了术前水平。双侧手臂的肩部力量均下降,且未恢复到术前水平。患侧手臂的肩部力量在术后即刻显著下降(降至术前水平的52.9%),直到第三次门诊就诊时才恢复(为术前水平的62.5%),而健侧手臂的肩部力量则逐渐下降(POD1时为83.1±2.3,POD24时为78.9±2.9)。从描述性角度来看,ROM的恢复模式可能因手术类型而异,而肩部力量的恢复模式则不然:无论手术类型如何,肩部力量均显著下降且恢复不明显。乳腺癌手术后的早期恢复阶段,无论手术类型如何,肩部ROM和力量均会降低,尽管力量下降的程度比ROM更大。我们的研究结果表明,双侧上肢均应进行康复锻炼。