Kanero Junko, Tunalı Elif Tutku, Oranç Cansu, Göksun Tilbe, Küntay Aylin C
Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Sabancı University, Istanbul, Turkey.
MPRG iSearch, Max Planck Institute for Human Development, Berlin, Germany.
Front Robot AI. 2021 Jun 30;8:679893. doi: 10.3389/frobt.2021.679893. eCollection 2021.
This study used an online second language (L2) vocabulary lesson to evaluate whether the physical body (i.e., embodiment) of a robot tutor has an impact on how the learner learns from the robot. In addition, we tested how individual differences in attitudes toward robots, first impressions of the robot, anxiety in learning L2, and personality traits may be related to L2 vocabulary learning. One hundred Turkish-speaking young adults were taught eight English words in a one-on-one Zoom session either with a NAO robot tutor ( = 50) or with a voice-only tutor ( = 50). The findings showed that participants learned the vocabulary equally well from the robot and voice tutors, indicating that the physical embodiment of the robot did not change learning gains in a short vocabulary lesson. Further, negative attitudes toward robots had negative effects on learning for participants in the robot tutor condition, but first impressions did not predict vocabulary learning in either of the two conditions. L2 anxiety, on the other hand, negatively predicted learning outcomes in both conditions. We also report that attitudes toward robots and the impressions of the robot tutor remained unchanged before and after the lesson. As one of the first to examine the effectiveness of robots as an online lecturer, this study presents an example of comparable learning outcomes regardless of physical embodiment.
本研究使用了一门在线第二语言(L2)词汇课程,以评估机器人导师的实体(即具身化)是否会对学习者向机器人学习的方式产生影响。此外,我们还测试了对机器人的态度、对机器人的第一印象、学习第二语言时的焦虑以及性格特征等个体差异可能如何与第二语言词汇学习相关。一百名讲土耳其语的年轻人在一对一的Zoom课程中学习八个英语单词,其中50人由NAO机器人导师授课,另外50人由纯语音导师授课。研究结果表明,参与者从机器人导师和语音导师那里学到的词汇同样好,这表明在短时间的词汇课程中,机器人的实体化并没有改变学习效果。此外,对机器人的负面态度对机器人导师组参与者的学习有负面影响,但第一印象在两种情况下均无法预测词汇学习情况。另一方面,第二语言学习焦虑在两种情况下均对学习结果有负面预测作用。我们还报告说,对机器人的态度和对机器人导师的印象在课程前后没有变化。作为最早研究机器人作为在线讲师有效性的研究之一,本研究提供了一个示例,表明无论实体化情况如何,学习结果都具有可比性。