Section of Hygiene, University Department of Life Sciences and Public Health, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Rome, Italy.
Department of Woman and Child Health and Public Health - Public Health Area, Fondazione Policlinico Universitario A. Gemelli IRCCS, Rome, Italy
BMJ Glob Health. 2021 Aug;6(8). doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2021-006422.
The objectives of the study were to calculate the standardised mortality rates (SMRs) for COVID-19 in European Union/European Economic Area countries plus the UK and Switzerland and to evaluate the correlation between SMRs and selected indicators in the first versus the subsequent waves until 23 June 2021. We used indirect standardisation (using Italy as the reference) to compute SMRs and considered 16 indicators of health and social well-being, health system capacity and COVID-19 response. The highest SMRs were in Belgium, the UK and Spain in the first wave (1.20-1.84) and in Hungary, Czechia and Slovakia in the subsequent waves (2.50-2.69). Human Development Index (HDI), life expectancy, urbanisation and healthcare expenditure had positive correlations with SMR in the first wave (rho=0.30-0.46), but negative correlations (rho=-0.67 to -0.47) in the subsequent waves. Retail/recreation mobility and transit mobility were negatively correlated with SMR in the first wave, while transit mobility was inversely correlated with SMR in the subsequent waves. The first wave hit most hard countries with high HDI, high life expectancy, high urbanisation, high health expenditures and high tourism. This pattern may reflect higher early community seeding and circulation of the virus. Conversely, in the subsequent waves, this pattern was completely inversed: countries with more resources and better health status did better than eastern European countries. While major SMR differences existed across countries in the first wave, these differences largely dissipated by 23 June 2021, with few exceptions.
本研究旨在计算欧盟/欧洲经济区国家(英国和瑞士除外)的 COVID-19 标准化死亡率(SMR),并评估在第一波和随后几波(截至 2021 年 6 月 23 日)中 SMR 与选定指标之间的相关性。我们使用间接标准化(以意大利为参照)来计算 SMR,并考虑了 16 项健康和社会福祉、卫生系统能力和 COVID-19 应对指标。第一波疫情中,比利时、英国和西班牙的 SMR 最高(1.20-1.84),随后几波疫情中,匈牙利、捷克和斯洛伐克的 SMR 最高(2.50-2.69)。在第一波疫情中,人类发展指数(HDI)、预期寿命、城市化和医疗支出与 SMR 呈正相关(rho=0.30-0.46),但在随后几波疫情中呈负相关(rho=-0.67 至-0.47)。第一波疫情中,零售/娱乐流动性和过境流动性与 SMR 呈负相关,而在随后几波疫情中,过境流动性与 SMR 呈负相关。第一波疫情对高人类发展指数、高预期寿命、高城市化、高医疗支出和高旅游业的国家打击最大。这种模式可能反映了病毒在早期社区传播和循环的程度更高。相反,在随后几波疫情中,这种模式完全颠倒:资源更多、健康状况更好的国家表现优于东欧国家。虽然在第一波疫情中各国之间存在显著的 SMR 差异,但到 2021 年 6 月 23 日,这些差异基本消失,只有少数例外。