Smayda Kirsten E, Worthy Darrell A, Chandrasekaran Bharath
Department of Psychology, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX, USA.
Department of Psychology, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, USA.
Psychol Music. 2018 Sep 1;46(5):734-748. doi: 10.1177/0305735617723721. Epub 2017 Aug 22.
Decision-making is critical to everyday life. Here we ask: to what extent does music training benefit decision-making? Supported by strong associations between music training and enhanced cross-domain skills, we hypothesize that musicians may show decision-making advantages relative to non-musicians. Prior work has also argued for a "critical period" for cross-domain plasticity such that beginning music training early enhances sensorimotor brain regions that mature early in life. Given that brain regions supporting decision-making begin maturing late in childhood, we hypothesized that an advantage in decision-making may only be present in musicians who began music training later in childhood. To test this hypothesis, young adults who began music training before and after 8 years of age (early-trained musicians, ET; late-trained musicians, LT, respectively) and non-musicians (NM) performed a decision-making task. We found a decision-making advantage in LT relative to ET and NM. To better understand the mechanism of the LT advantage, we conducted computational modeling on participant responses and found that LT were less biased by recent outcomes and incorporated longer strings of outcomes when deciding among the choice options. These results tentatively suggest that music training may confer decision-making enhancements, and carry strong implications for the utility of music training in childhood.
决策对日常生活至关重要。在此我们提出疑问:音乐训练在多大程度上有益于决策?鉴于音乐训练与增强的跨领域技能之间存在紧密关联,我们推测音乐家相对于非音乐家可能展现出决策优势。先前的研究也主张跨领域可塑性存在一个“关键期”,即早期开始音乐训练会增强在生命早期成熟的感觉运动脑区。鉴于支持决策的脑区在童年后期才开始成熟,我们推测决策优势可能仅存在于童年后期开始音乐训练的音乐家中。为了验证这一假设,在8岁之前和之后开始音乐训练的年轻成年人(分别为早期训练的音乐家,ET;后期训练的音乐家,LT)以及非音乐家(NM)进行了一项决策任务。我们发现LT相对于ET和NM具有决策优势。为了更好地理解LT优势的机制,我们对参与者的反应进行了计算建模,发现LT在选择选项时受近期结果的偏差较小,并且在决策时纳入了更长的结果序列。这些结果初步表明音乐训练可能带来决策能力的提升,并对童年时期音乐训练的效用具有重要意义。