Department of Radiology, Graduate School of Medicine, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Department of Radiology, Teikyo University Hospital, Mizonokuchi, Kanagawa, Japan.
J Neuroimaging. 2022 Jan;32(1):111-119. doi: 10.1111/jon.12916. Epub 2021 Aug 13.
To examine whether feature-fusion (FF) method improves single-shot detector's (SSD's) detection of small brain metastases on contrast-enhanced (CE) T1-weighted MRI.
The study included 234 MRI scans from 234 patients (64.3 years±12.0; 126 men). The ground-truth annotation was performed semiautomatically. SSDs with and without an FF module were developed and trained using 178 scans. The detection performance was evaluated at the SSDs' 50% confidence threshold using sensitivity, positive-predictive value (PPV), and the false-positive (FP) per scan with the remaining 56 scans.
FF-SSD achieved an overall sensitivity of 86.0% (95% confidence interval [CI]: [83.0%, 85.6%]; 196/228) and 46.8% PPV (95% CI: [42.0%, 46.3%]; 196/434), with 4.3 FP (95% CI: [4.3, 4.9]). Lesions smaller than 3 mm had 45.8% sensitivity (95% CI: [36.1%, 45.5%]; 22/48) with 2.0 FP (95% CI: [1.9, 2.1]). Lesions measuring 3-6 mm had 92.3% sensitivity (95% CI: [86.5%, 92.0%]; 48/52) with 1.8 FP (95% CI: [1.7, 2.2]). Lesions larger than 6 mm had 98.4% sensitivity (95% CI: [97.8%, 99.4%]; 126/128) 0.5 FP (95% CI: [0.5, 0.8]) per scan. FF-SSD had a significantly higher sensitivity for lesions < 3 mm (p = 0.008, t = 3.53) than the baseline SSD, while the overall PPV was similar (p = 0.06, t = -2.16). A similar trend was observed even when the detector's confidence threshold was varied as low as 0.2, for which the FF-SSD's sensitivity was 91.2% and the FP was 9.5.
The FF-SSD algorithm identified brain metastases on CE T1-weighted MRI with high accuracy.
探究特征融合(FF)方法是否能提高单次检测(SSD)对增强对比 T1 加权 MRI 中小脑转移瘤的检测能力。
本研究纳入了 234 例患者(64.3 岁±12.0;126 例男性)的 234 例 MRI 扫描。采用半自动方法进行了地面实况注释。使用 178 例扫描对带有和不带有 FF 模块的 SSD 进行了开发和训练。使用其余 56 例扫描,以灵敏度、阳性预测值(PPV)和每例扫描的假阳性(FP)来评估 SSD 在其 50%置信度阈值下的检测性能。
FF-SSD 的总体灵敏度为 86.0%(95%置信区间[CI]:[83.0%,85.6%];196/228),PPV 为 46.8%(95% CI:[42.0%,46.3%];196/434),FP 为 4.3(95% CI:[4.3,4.9])。小于 3mm 的病灶的灵敏度为 45.8%(95% CI:[36.1%,45.5%];22/48),FP 为 2.0(95% CI:[1.9,2.1])。3-6mm 的病灶灵敏度为 92.3%(95% CI:[86.5%,92.0%];48/52),FP 为 1.8(95% CI:[1.7,2.2])。大于 6mm 的病灶灵敏度为 98.4%(95% CI:[97.8%,99.4%];126/128),每例扫描 FP 为 0.5(95% CI:[0.5,0.8])。FF-SSD 对小于 3mm 的病灶的灵敏度明显高于基线 SSD(p = 0.008,t = 3.53),而总体 PPV 相似(p = 0.06,t = -2.16)。即使将探测器的置信度阈值降低到 0.2,也观察到了类似的趋势,此时 FF-SSD 的灵敏度为 91.2%,FP 为 9.5。
FF-SSD 算法在检测增强对比 T1 加权 MRI 中的脑转移瘤方面具有较高的准确性。