Kostenzer Johanna, Hoffmann Julia, von Rosenstiel-Pulver Charlotte, Walsh Aisling, Zimmermann Luc J I, Mader Silke
European Foundation for the Care of Newborn Infants (EFCNI), Scientific Affairs, Hofmannstrasse 7A, Munich 81379, Germany.
Department of Paediatrics, Research School Oncology and Development, Maastricht UMC+, Maastricht, the Netherlands.
EClinicalMedicine. 2021 Aug 6;39:101056. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2021.101056. eCollection 2021 Sep.
The COVID-19 pandemic restrictions affect provision and quality of neonatal care. This global study explores parents' experiences regarding the impact of the restrictions on key characteristics of infant and family-centred developmental care (IFCDC) during the first year of the pandemic.
For this cross-sectional study, a pre-tested online survey with 52 questions and translated into 23 languages was used to collect data between August and November 2020. Parents of sick or preterm infants born during the pandemic and receiving special/intensive care were eligible for participation. Data analysis included descriptive statistics and statistical testing based on different levels of restrictive measures.
In total, 2103 participants from 56 countries provided interpretable data. Fifty-two percent of respondents were not allowed to have another person present during birth. Percentages increased with the extent of restrictions in the respondents' country of residence ( = 0·002). Twenty-one percent of total respondents indicated that no-one was allowed to be present with the infant receiving special/intensive care. The frequency ( < 0·001) and duration ( = 0·001) of permitted presence largely depended on the extent of restrictions. The more restrictive the policy measures were, the more the respondents worried about the pandemic situation during pregnancy and after birth.
COVID-19 related restrictions severely challenged evidence-based cornerstones of IFCDC, such as separating parents/ legal guardians and their newborns. Our findings must therefore be considered by public health experts and policy makers alike to reduce unnecessary suffering, calling for a zero separation policy.
EFCNI received an earmarked donation by Novartis Pharma AG in support of this study.
2019冠状病毒病疫情限制措施影响了新生儿护理的提供和质量。这项全球研究探讨了在疫情第一年,父母对于这些限制措施对以婴儿和家庭为中心的发育护理(IFCDC)关键特征影响的体验。
在这项横断面研究中,2020年8月至11月期间,使用了一份经过预测试的、有52个问题且翻译成23种语言的在线调查问卷来收集数据。疫情期间出生且正在接受特殊/重症护理的患病或早产婴儿的父母有资格参与。数据分析包括描述性统计以及基于不同限制措施水平的统计检验。
来自56个国家的2103名参与者提供了可解释的数据。52%的受访者在分娩时不被允许有其他人在场。这一比例随着受访者居住国家限制措施的程度增加而上升(P = 0.002)。21%的受访者表示,在婴儿接受特殊/重症护理期间不允许任何人在场。允许陪伴的频率(P < 0.001)和时长(P = 0.001)在很大程度上取决于限制措施的程度。政策措施限制越严格,受访者在孕期和产后对疫情形势的担忧就越大。
与2019冠状病毒病相关的限制措施严重挑战了IFCDC的循证基石,比如将父母/法定监护人与他们的新生儿分开。因此,公共卫生专家和政策制定者都必须考虑我们的研究结果,以减少不必要的痛苦,呼吁实行零分离政策。
欧洲新生儿重症监护倡议组织(EFCNI)收到了诺华制药有限公司的专项捐赠以支持这项研究。