Department of Health Policy and Management, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland.
Department of Health Policy and Management, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland.
Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2022 Winter;34(4):1160-1165. doi: 10.1053/j.semtcvs.2021.08.010. Epub 2021 Aug 15.
In low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), 93% of the population lacks safe, timely, and affordable access to cardiac surgical care when needed. As countries slowly build or expand local, independent cardiac centers, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) partially bridge the gap in cardiac surgical care delivery in LMICs. However, little is known about the current scope of cardiac NGOs. Here, we perform an analysis of active NGOs involved with the delivery of cardiac surgical services in LMICs or for patients from LMICs. Cardiac surgery NGOs were identified from medical literature, established NGO databases, and Google Scholar searches. The search was performed between December 2019 and May 2020. NGOs whose websites were not updated or described missions or projects taking place no later than 2015 were considered inactive. Eighty-six NGOs are actively providing cardiac surgery services in LMICs or treating patients from LMICs. Five NGOs performed adult cardiac surgery only, 56 performed pediatric cardiac surgery only, and 25 performed both adult and pediatric cardiac surgery. NGOs originated from 23 different countries and were operational in a total of 111 countries, 96 of them being LMICs. Fifty-three NGOs reported data on annual surgical volume, of which half performed less than 50 operations per year. NGOs effectively address the burden of cardiac surgical disease in LMICs and contribute to local capacity-building. Increased, more detailed, and standardized reporting of the impact and outcomes of NGOs is necessary to better understand annual cardiac surgical volume and to support local centers working towards independent services.
在中低收入国家(LMICs),有 93%的人口在需要时无法安全、及时、负担得起地获得心脏外科护理。随着各国逐渐建立或扩大本地、独立的心脏中心,非政府组织(NGO)在一定程度上弥补了 LMICs 心脏外科护理服务提供方面的差距。然而,对于当前心脏 NGO 的范围却知之甚少。在这里,我们对参与 LMIC 心脏外科服务或为来自 LMIC 的患者提供服务的活跃 NGO 进行了分析。心脏手术 NGO 是从医学文献、已建立的 NGO 数据库和 Google Scholar 搜索中确定的。搜索是在 2019 年 12 月至 2020 年 5 月之间进行的。如果 NGO 的网站没有更新,或者描述的使命或项目最晚不晚于 2015 年已经结束,则认为其不再活跃。目前有 86 个 NGO 在 LMIC 提供心脏手术服务或治疗来自 LMIC 的患者。其中 5 个 NGO 只进行成人心脏手术,56 个 NGO 只进行儿科心脏手术,25 个 NGO 同时进行成人和儿科心脏手术。这些 NGO 来自 23 个不同的国家,在总共 111 个国家开展业务,其中 96 个是 LMICs。其中 53 个 NGO 报告了年度手术量数据,其中一半每年的手术量不到 50 例。NGO 有效地解决了 LMIC 中心脏外科疾病的负担,并有助于当地能力建设。需要增加、更详细和标准化的 NGO 影响和结果报告,以便更好地了解年度心脏手术量,并支持朝着独立服务方向努力的当地中心。