Haque Waqas, Gurney Troy, Reed W Gary, North Carol S, Pollio David E, Pollio E Whitney, Wagner James M
University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, 5323 Harry Hines Blvd., Dallas, TX 75390-9006 USA.
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, Dallas, TX USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2019 May 15;29(3):721-730. doi: 10.1007/s40670-019-00746-w. eCollection 2019 Sep.
The purpose of this study was to discover the elements required for a successful learning community (LC) faculty member educator of medical students.
The authors in this qualitative study evaluated six 90-min focus groups of faculty members. The groups included 31 experienced and 19 inexperienced LC faculty members at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical School. After achieving excellent interrater reliability, transcriptions of the discussions were subjected to thematic analysis using ATLAS.ti software.
Five major themes emerged: (1) LC faculty characteristics/competency, (2) suggested faculty development methods, (3) factors outside the LC environment influencing student relationships, (4) student attributes influencing teaching techniques, and (5) measuring and improving history and physical skills. Faculty characteristics/competency subthemes included role-modeling, mentoring, and teaching competence. Suggested faculty development methods subthemes included assessing and giving feedback to faculty, peer development, and learning from experts. Experienced LC faculty focused more attention on teaching competence and mentoring competence than inexperienced LC faculty.
The themes with the most extensive discussion among the experienced LC faculty groups may represent qualities to be sought in future mentor recruitment and faculty development. Future studies could build on this study by similarly investigating student perceptions.
本研究旨在发现成为成功的医学生学习社区(LC)教员所需的要素。
在这项定性研究中,作者评估了6个由教员组成的90分钟焦点小组。这些小组包括德克萨斯大学西南医学中心的31名经验丰富的LC教员和19名经验不足的LC教员。在实现了良好的评分者间信度后,使用ATLAS.ti软件对讨论记录进行主题分析。
出现了五个主要主题:(1)LC教员的特征/能力,(2)建议的教员发展方法,(3)LC环境之外影响师生关系的因素,(4)影响教学技巧的学生属性,以及(5)测量和提高病史与体格检查技能。教员特征/能力子主题包括树立榜样、指导和教学能力。建议的教员发展方法子主题包括对教员进行评估和反馈、同伴发展以及向专家学习。与经验不足的LC教员相比,经验丰富的LC教员更关注教学能力和指导能力。
经验丰富的LC教员小组中讨论最广泛的主题可能代表了未来在招募导师和教员发展中应寻求的品质。未来的研究可以在此研究的基础上,类似地调查学生的看法。