Department of Psychology, 54724Ateneo de Manila University, Quezon City, Philippines.
Center for Child and Family Policy, 3065Duke University, Durham, NC, USA.
Child Maltreat. 2022 Nov;27(4):561-571. doi: 10.1177/10775595211036401. Epub 2021 Aug 14.
We examined whether a policy banning corporal punishment enacted in Kenya in 2010 is associated with changes in Kenyan caregivers' use of corporal punishment and beliefs in its effectiveness and normativeness, and compared to caregivers in six countries without bans in the same period. Using a longitudinal study with six waves of panel data (2008-2016), mothers ( = 1086) in Colombia, Italy, Jordan, Kenya, Philippines, Thailand, and United States reported household use of corporal punishment and beliefs about its effectiveness and normativeness. Random intercept models and multi-group piecewise growth curve models indicated that the proportion of corporal punishment behaviors used by the Kenyan caregivers decreased post-ban at a significantly different rate compared to the caregivers in other countries in the same period. Beliefs of effectiveness of corporal punishment were declining among the caregivers in all sites, whereas the Kenyan mothers reported increasing perceptions of normativeness of corporal punishment post-ban, different from the other sites. While other contributing factors cannot be ruled out, our natural experiment suggests that corporal punishment decreased after a national ban, a shift that was not evident in sites without bans in the same period.
我们研究了 2010 年在肯尼亚颁布的禁止体罚政策是否与肯尼亚照顾者使用体罚以及对其有效性和规范性的看法的变化有关,并将其与同期没有禁令的六个国家的照顾者进行了比较。本研究使用了一个具有六个波次面板数据(2008-2016 年)的纵向研究,来自哥伦比亚、意大利、约旦、肯尼亚、菲律宾、泰国和美国的母亲(n=1086)报告了家庭体罚使用情况以及对体罚有效性和规范性的看法。随机截距模型和多组分段增长曲线模型表明,与同期其他国家的照顾者相比,肯尼亚照顾者在禁令后体罚行为的比例下降速度明显不同。所有地点的照顾者对体罚有效性的信念都在下降,而肯尼亚母亲在禁令后报告体罚规范性的看法增加,与其他地点不同。虽然不能排除其他因素的影响,但我们的自然实验表明,在全国范围内禁止体罚后,体罚行为有所减少,而在同期没有禁令的地方,这种变化并不明显。