Soderberg G L, Minor S D, Arnold K, Henry T, Chatterson J K, Poppe D R, Wall C
Physical Therapy Program, College of Medicine, University of Iowa, Iowa City 52242.
Phys Ther. 1987 Nov;67(11):1691-6. doi: 10.1093/ptj/67.11.1691.
Little information exists about the intensity of contraction required from knee and hip musculature during common therapeutic exercises used for patient populations. This study, therefore, was designed to compare electromyographic data obtained from the vastus medialis, rectus femoris, gluteus medius, and biceps femoris muscles during maximally resisted straight-leg-raising (SLR) exercises with EMG data obtained from the same muscles during quadriceps femoris muscle setting (QS) exercises in healthy subjects and in patients with knee pathologies. Of the 30 participants in the study, 16 had a history of knee injury or surgery. All participants performed randomly ordered trials of the SLR and QS exercises while the EMG data were recorded from surface electrodes and normalized to values derived from maximal effort isometric contraction trials. An analysis of variance demonstrated significantly greater activity (p less than .05) of the vastus medialis, biceps femoris, and gluteus medius muscles during QS exercises than during SLR exercises. The rectus femoris muscle was significantly more active (p less than .05) during SLR exercises than during QS exercises. The study demonstrated remarkably different degrees of muscle activation between the SLR and QS exercises, indicating that the exercise selected will affect the therapeutic intention.
关于针对患者群体进行的常见治疗性锻炼中,膝关节和髋关节肌肉所需的收缩强度,目前所知甚少。因此,本研究旨在比较健康受试者和患有膝关节疾病的患者在进行最大抗阻直腿抬高(SLR)锻炼时,股内侧肌、股直肌、臀中肌和股二头肌所获得的肌电图数据,与在股四头肌静力收缩(QS)锻炼时从相同肌肉获得的肌电图数据。在该研究的30名参与者中,16人有膝关节损伤或手术史。所有参与者在进行SLR和QS锻炼时按随机顺序进行试验,同时从表面电极记录肌电图数据,并将其标准化为从最大努力等长收缩试验得出的值。方差分析表明,在QS锻炼期间,股内侧肌、股二头肌和臀中肌的活动明显高于(p小于0.05)SLR锻炼期间。股直肌在SLR锻炼期间的活动明显高于(p小于0.05)QS锻炼期间。该研究表明,SLR和QS锻炼之间的肌肉激活程度存在显著差异,这表明所选择的锻炼方式会影响治疗意图。