School of Nursing, Nagoya University of Arts and Sciences, Nagoya, Japan.
Faculty of Human Care at Numazu, Tohto University, Numazu, Japan.
Nagoya J Med Sci. 2021 Aug;83(3):477-493. doi: 10.18999/nagjms.83.3.477.
Moral sensitivity is important for both, qualified nurses and nursing students. Currently, however, the instruments to measure moral sensitivity exist for qualified nurses only. The objective of this study is to develop a valid and reliable instrument to assess moral sensitivity of nursing students and to examine the development and differentiation of this sensitivity by school year, clinical training, and other educational variables. The study comprised semi-structured focus group interviews and a survey using a self-administered questionnaire. The questionnaire was developed using data obtained from the focus groups and distributed to 1,995 nursing students in three Bachelor of Science in Nursing programs (BScN) and eight Nursing Diploma programs. Completed questionnaires were obtained from 473 nursing students. An exploratory factor analysis indicated that 11 items and 3 factors were extracted: "Moral Strength," "Sense of Moral Burden," and "Moral Responsibility." The factors each demonstrated acceptable content- and criterion-related validity with the Resilience Measurement Scale for University Students. This three-factor structure was consistent with that of the Japanese version of the revised Moral Sensitivity Questionnaire. The mean score of each item ranged from 2.75 to 4.74 (SD = 1.04 - 1.34). A comparison of inter-year scores showed that third-year students had significantly higher Moral Strength scores in both the BScN and Nursing Diploma programs. The 11-item questionnaire developed for this study was consistent with a three-factor structure of registered nurses' moral sensitivity and successfully identified differences in moral sensitivity among nursing students. Using this type of questionnaire will allow nursing programs to improve the moral sensitivity of nursing students by allowing lecturers to develop tailored moral sensitivity programs.
道德敏感性对合格护士和护理学生都很重要。然而,目前衡量道德敏感性的工具仅适用于合格护士。本研究的目的是开发一种有效的、可靠的工具来评估护理学生的道德敏感性,并研究通过学年、临床培训和其他教育变量来考察这种敏感性的发展和分化。该研究包括半结构化焦点小组访谈和使用自我管理问卷的调查。该问卷是使用焦点小组获得的数据开发的,并分发给三个护理学士课程(BScN)和八个护理文凭课程的 1995 名护理学生。从 473 名护理学生中获得了完整的问卷。探索性因素分析表明,从 11 个项目中提取了 3 个因素:“道德力量”、“道德负担感”和“道德责任感”。这些因素与大学生弹性测量量表的内容和标准相关效度均得到了认可。这种三因素结构与修订后的道德敏感性问卷的日语版本一致。每个项目的平均得分范围为 2.75 至 4.74(SD = 1.04-1.34)。对各年级成绩的比较表明,BScN 和护理文凭课程的三年级学生的“道德力量”得分明显更高。本研究开发的 11 项问卷与注册护士道德敏感性的三因素结构一致,并成功识别了护理学生之间道德敏感性的差异。使用这种类型的问卷可以让护理课程通过让讲师开发量身定制的道德敏感性课程来提高护理学生的道德敏感性。