Zucchini Riccardo, Sambri Andrea, Fiore Michele, Giannini Claudio, Donati Davide Maria, De Paolis Massimiliano
IRCCS Istituto Ortopedico Rizzoli, Bologna, Italy.
IRCCS Policlinico di Sant'Orsola, Bologna, Italy.
Hip Pelvis. 2021 Sep;33(3):147-153. doi: 10.5371/hp.2021.33.3.147. Epub 2021 Sep 6.
Reconstruction of the proximal femur after tumour resection can be performed with proximal femoral endopros-theses (PFE). Many studies have reported that bipolar hemiarthroplasty (BHA) reduce the risk of dislocation after oncological resections. However, progressive cotyloiditis which might require acetabular resurfacing (total hip arthroplasty [THA]) has been reported. The aim of this study is to compare the results of BHA and THA after proximal femur resection.
A total of 104 consecutive patients affected by primary (n=52) and metastatic (n=52) bone tumours were included. Ninety patients underwent BHA and 14 patients underwent THA. Complications were recorded and classified according to the Henderson classification. At final follow-up, patients with the implant in site were functionally evaluated with modified Harris hip score (HHS).
The mean follow-up was 50 months (range, 2-171 months). Twenty-four (23.1%) patients developed major complications. Eleven (12.2%) BHA required acetabular resurfacing. Patients affected by primary bone tumours showed an increased risk of THA conversion (=0.042). A reduced risk was observed in patients younger than 35 years (=0.043) and in those older than 65 years (=0.033). Dislocation occurred in four case (3.8%), in particular after THA (=0.021). At final follow-up, 93 patients had the prosthesis in site (80 BHA and 13 THA). Mean postoperative HHS was 70 (range, 30-90).
The risk of dislocation is lower for bipolar endoprosthesis compared to THA. However cotyloiditis and acetabular resurfacing might occurred.
股骨近端肿瘤切除术后可采用股骨近端内置假体(PFE)进行重建。许多研究报告称,双极半髋关节置换术(BHA)可降低肿瘤切除术后脱位的风险。然而,有报道称可能需要进行髋臼表面置换(全髋关节置换术[THA])的进行性髋臼炎。本研究的目的是比较股骨近端切除术后BHA和THA的结果。
共纳入104例连续的原发性(n = 52)和转移性(n = 52)骨肿瘤患者。90例患者接受了BHA,14例患者接受了THA。根据亨德森分类法记录并分类并发症。在最后随访时,对在位植入物的患者采用改良Harris髋关节评分(HHS)进行功能评估。
平均随访时间为50个月(范围2 - 171个月)。24例(23.1%)患者出现严重并发症。11例(12.2%)BHA需要进行髋臼表面置换。原发性骨肿瘤患者THA转换风险增加(P = 0.042)。35岁以下患者(P = 0.043)和65岁以上患者(P = 0.033)风险降低。4例(3.8%)发生脱位,尤其是THA术后(P = 0.021)。在最后随访时,93例患者在位有假体(80例BHA和13例THA)。术后平均HHS为70(范围30 - 90)。
与THA相比,双极假体脱位风险较低。然而,可能会发生髋臼炎和髋臼表面置换。