Markham R H, Carter C, Scobie M A, Metcalf C, Easty D L
Trans Ophthalmol Soc U K (1962). 1977 Jul;97(2):333-40.
The results are reported of a fully controlled randomized double-blind clincial trial of adenine arabinoside and idoxuridine ointment in sixty patients with herpetic ulceration of the cornea. Although both antivirals showed a trend towards superiority over placebo, the therapeutic effect did not reach statistical significance in spite of the known efficacy in laboratory animals. Further studies in rabbits are reported; these indicate that systemic immunity may play a role in combating virus proliferation in recurrent disease, and it is considered this disguises the efficacy of topical antiviral therapy in clinical trials, thus necessitating an estimated requirement for approximately fifty patients per treatment group to obtain significant effects. It is concluded that an antiviral is valuable in the treatment of ulcerative herpetic keratitis, particularly in primary disease and in the presence of systemic and local immunosuppression after the use of topical adrenocorticosteroid. In recurrent disease, where a trigger factor is known, experience has shown that therapy can be profitably administered before the onset of clinical disease.
报告了一项关于阿糖腺苷和碘苷眼膏治疗60例角膜疱疹性溃疡患者的完全对照随机双盲临床试验结果。尽管两种抗病毒药物均显示出优于安慰剂的趋势,但尽管在实验动物中已知其疗效,但治疗效果未达到统计学显著性。报告了在兔子身上进行的进一步研究;这些研究表明,全身免疫可能在复发性疾病中对抗病毒增殖起作用,并且认为这掩盖了局部抗病毒治疗在临床试验中的疗效,因此每个治疗组估计需要约50名患者才能获得显著效果。得出的结论是,抗病毒药物在溃疡性疱疹性角膜炎的治疗中是有价值的,特别是在原发性疾病以及局部使用肾上腺皮质类固醇后出现全身和局部免疫抑制的情况下。在已知触发因素的复发性疾病中,经验表明在临床疾病发作前进行治疗可能有益。