Brunel University London, Kingston Lane, London, Uxbridge, UB8 3PN, UK.
University of Wolverhampton, Wulfruna Street, Wolverhampton, WV1 1 LY, UK.
Psychol Res. 2022 Jul;86(5):1535-1546. doi: 10.1007/s00426-021-01595-2. Epub 2021 Sep 26.
Comprehension assesses a listener's ability to construe the meaning of an acoustic signal in order to be able to answer questions about its contents, while intelligibility indicates the extent to which a listener can precisely retrieve the acoustic signal. Previous comprehension studies asking listeners for sentence-level information or narrative-level information used native listeners as participants. This is the first study to look at whether clear speech properties (e.g. expanded vowel space) produce a clear speech benefit at the word level for L2 learners for speech produced in naturalistic settings. This study explored whether hyperarticulated speech was more comprehensible than non-hyperarticulated speech for both L1 British English speakers and early and late L2 British English learners in quiet and in noise. Sixteen British English listeners, 16 native Mandarin Chinese listeners as early learners of L2 and 16 native Mandarin Chinese listeners as late learners of L2 rated hyperarticulated samples versus non-hyperarticulated samples in form of words for comprehension under four listening conditions of varying white noise level (quiet or SNR levels of + 16 dB, + 12 dB or + 8 dB) (3 × 2× 4 mixed design). Mean ratings showed all three groups found hyperarticulated speech samples easier to understand than non-hyperarticulated speech at all listening conditions. Results are discussed in terms of other findings (Uther et al., 2012) that suggest that hyperarticulation may generally improve speech processing for all language groups.
理解评估听众构建声音信号含义的能力,以便能够回答有关其内容的问题,而可理解度则表示听众能够准确检索声音信号的程度。以前的理解研究要求听众提供句子级或叙述级信息,参与者都是以母语为英语的听众。这是第一项研究,旨在探讨在自然环境中产生的言语中,对于 L2 学习者来说,清晰言语特性(例如扩展的元音空间)是否在单词水平上产生清晰言语优势。本研究探讨了在安静和噪声环境中,对于母语为英语的 L1 使用者以及早期和晚期 L2 英语学习者,超发音言语是否比非超发音言语更具可理解性。16 名英国英语听众、16 名早期 L2 英语学习者和 16 名晚期 L2 英语学习者作为母语为普通话的听众,对超发音样本和非超发音样本进行了词汇形式的理解评分,在四种不同白噪声水平(安静或 SNR 水平为+16dB、+12dB 或+8dB)的四个听力条件下(3×2×4 混合设计)。平均评分显示,所有三组在所有听力条件下都发现超发音言语样本比非超发音言语样本更容易理解。结果根据其他发现(Uther 等人,2012)进行了讨论,这些发现表明超发音可能普遍改善所有语言群体的言语处理。