Ghotbi Nader, Ho Manh Tung
Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University, Oita, Beppu Japan.
Centre for Interdisciplinary Social Research, Phenikaa University, Yen Nghia, Ha Dong Hanoi, Vietnam.
Asian Bioeth Rev. 2021 Sep 3;13(4):421-433. doi: 10.1007/s41649-021-00182-2. eCollection 2021 Dec.
To evaluate the moral awareness of college students regarding artificial intelligence (AI) systems, we have examined 467 surveys collected from 152 Japanese and 315 non-Japanese students in an international university in Japan. The students were asked to choose a most significant moral problem of AI applications in the future from a list of ten ethical issues and to write an essay about it. The results show that most of the students (n = 269, 58%) considered unemployment to be the major ethical issue related to AI. The second largest group of students (n = 54, 12%) was concerned with ethical issues related to emotional AI, including the impact of AI on human behavior and emotion and robots' rights and emotions. A relatively small number of students referred to the risk of social control by AI (6%), AI discrimination (6%), increasing inequality (5%), loss of privacy (4%), AI mistakes (3%), malicious AI (3%), and AI security breaches (3%). Calculation of the score for two population proportions shows that Japanese students were much less concerned about AI control of society (- 3.1276, < 0.01) than non-Japanese students, but more concerned about discrimination (2.2757, < 0.05). Female students were less concerned about unemployment (- 2.6108, < 0.01) than males, but more concerned about discrimination (2.4333, < 0.05). The study concludes that the moral awareness of college students regarding AI technologies is quite limited and recommends including the ethics of AI in the curriculum.
为了评估大学生对人工智能(AI)系统的道德认知,我们对从日本一所国际大学的152名日本学生和315名非日本学生收集的467份调查问卷进行了研究。这些学生被要求从十个伦理问题列表中选出未来人工智能应用中最重要的道德问题,并就此写一篇短文。结果显示,大多数学生(n = 269,58%)认为失业是与人工智能相关的主要伦理问题。第二大群体的学生(n = 54,12%)关注与情感人工智能相关的伦理问题,包括人工智能对人类行为和情感的影响以及机器人的权利和情感。相对较少的学生提到了人工智能的社会控制风险(6%)、人工智能歧视(6%)、不平等加剧(5%)、隐私丧失(4%)、人工智能错误(3%)、恶意人工智能(3%)和人工智能安全漏洞(3%)。对两个人口比例得分的计算表明,日本学生比非日本学生对人工智能控制社会的担忧要少得多(-3.1276,<0.01),但对歧视问题更为关注(2.2757,<0.05)。女学生比男学生对失业问题的担忧要少(-2.6108,<0.01),但对歧视问题更为关注(2.4333,<0.05)。该研究得出结论,大学生对人工智能技术的道德认知相当有限,并建议将人工智能伦理纳入课程。