Wang Zhao, Zhu Haojie, Li Xiaofei, Yao Yan, Liu Zhimin, Fan Xiaohan
Department of Cardiology, Fuwai Hospital, National Center for Cardiovascular Diseases, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China.
Front Cardiovasc Med. 2021 Sep 23;8:695531. doi: 10.3389/fcvm.2021.695531. eCollection 2021.
Left bundle branch area pacing (LBBAP) is a novel physiological pacing approach. To assess learning curve for LBBAP and compare the procedure and fluoroscopy time between LBBAP and right ventricular pacing (RVP). Consecutive bradycardia patients who underwent LBBAP or RVP were prospectively recruited from June 2018 to June 2020. The procedure and fluoroscopy time for ventricular lead placement, pacing parameters, and periprocedural complications were recorded. Restricted cubic splines were used to fit learning curves for LBBAP. Left bundle branch area pacing was successful in 376 of 406 (92.6%) patients while 313 patients received RVP. Learning curve for LBBAP illustrated initial (1-50 cases), improved (51-150 cases), and stable stages (151-406 cases) with gradually increased success rates (88.0 vs. 90.0 vs. 94.5%, = 0.106), steeply decreased median procedure (26.5 vs. 14.0 vs. 9.0min, < 0.001) and fluoroscopy time (16.0 vs. 6.0 vs. 4.0min, < 0.001), and shortened stimulus to left ventricular activation time (Sti-LVAT; 78.7 vs. 78.1 vs. 71.2 ms, < 0.001). LBBAP at the stable stage showed longer but close median procedure (9.0 vs. 6.9min, < 0.001) and fluoroscopy time (4.0 vs. 2.8min, < 0.001) compared with RVP. The procedure and fluoroscopy time of LBBAP could be reduced significantly with increasing procedure volume and close to that of RVP for an experienced operator.
左束支区域起搏(LBBAP)是一种新型的生理性起搏方法。旨在评估LBBAP的学习曲线,并比较LBBAP与右心室起搏(RVP)之间的手术过程和透视时间。2018年6月至2020年6月前瞻性招募了接受LBBAP或RVP的连续性心动过缓患者。记录心室导线植入的手术过程和透视时间、起搏参数及围手术期并发症。采用受限立方样条拟合LBBAP的学习曲线。406例患者中有376例(92.6%)LBBAP成功,313例患者接受了RVP。LBBAP的学习曲线显示出初始阶段(1 - 50例)、改善阶段(51 - 150例)和稳定阶段(151 - 406例),成功率逐渐提高(88.0%对90.0%对94.5%,P = 0.106),中位手术时间大幅缩短(26.5分钟对14.0分钟对9.0分钟,P < 0.001),透视时间缩短(16.0分钟对6.0分钟对4.0分钟,P < 0.001),刺激至左心室激动时间(Sti - LVAT)缩短(78.7毫秒对78.1毫秒对71.2毫秒,P < 0.001)。与RVP相比,稳定阶段的LBBAP中位手术时间更长但相近(9.0分钟对6.9分钟,P < 0.001),透视时间更长(4.0分钟对2.8分钟,P < 0.001)。随着手术量增加,LBBAP的手术过程和透视时间可显著缩短,对于经验丰富的操作者,可接近RVP的水平。