Nisar Sumera, Mahboob Usman, Khan Rehan Ahmed, Rehman Durraiz
Batterjee Medical college, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
University of Lahore, Lahore, Pakistan.
BMC Med Educ. 2021 Oct 13;21(1):530. doi: 10.1186/s12909-021-02959-3.
Online communication has taken over in the last 2 years due to the frequent lockdowns because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Overburdened physicians in this pandemic are struggling to get enough time to teach clinical skills online to the students. Also, due to student's safety issues, the students cannot fully attend the clinics. Therefore, in this scenario, online PAL (Peer Assisted Learning) sessions for clinical skill teaching and learning can be an effective alternative for undergraduate medical students. The academic limitations caused by the COVID-19 related lockdown however can have a pleasurable outcome if certain challenges, related to online PAL, are overcome. Therefore, the present study aims to identify the challenges of Peer Assisted Learning (PAL) sessions during online clinical skills training in the Ophthalmology module of undergraduate medical students.
This qualitative exploratory study, utilizing online focus group discussions to explore the challenges of online PAL in training and learning of clinical skills were carried at the Ophthalmology department of Batterjee Medical College, Jeddah; Saudi Arabia. A purposive convenient sampling technique was used to collect data. Data were transcribed and analyzed using thematic analysis.
The study identified six themes that were further divided into smaller subthemes. The subthemes derived from the collected data were organized under the following major themes; infrastructure, learning environment, psychological problems, interaction deficit, learning desires, and desire for feedback on performance. The major challenge reported by the medical student during online PAL sessions was infrastructure in terms of network connection, scheduling, and timing of the session. The unprofessional learning environment, psychological problems in terms of behavioral issues and personality changes, interaction deficit with peers, tutor, and patient, learning desires, and desire for feedback on performance were the other important challenges faced by the students.
The challenges explored by our study can be used by the medical educators to incorporate online PAL as an effective, efficient, and alternative teaching and learning modality in the curriculum especially in compromised circumstances like the current COVID-19 pandemic.
在过去两年中,由于新冠疫情导致频繁封锁,在线交流占据了主导。在这场疫情中,负担过重的医生难以抽出足够时间在线上向学生传授临床技能。此外,出于学生安全问题,学生无法充分参与临床实习。因此,在这种情况下,用于临床技能教学的在线同伴辅助学习(PAL)课程对于本科医学生而言可能是一种有效的替代方式。然而,如果能够克服与在线PAL相关的某些挑战,新冠疫情相关封锁所造成的学业限制可能会产生有益的结果。因此,本研究旨在确定本科医学生眼科模块在线临床技能培训期间同伴辅助学习(PAL)课程所面临的挑战。
这项定性探索性研究在沙特阿拉伯吉达的巴特吉医学院眼科开展,利用在线焦点小组讨论来探究在线PAL在临床技能培训与学习方面所面临的挑战。采用目的便利抽样技术收集数据。数据经转录后使用主题分析法进行分析。
该研究确定了六个主题,这些主题又进一步细分为更小的子主题。从收集到的数据中得出的子主题被归纳在以下主要主题之下:基础设施、学习环境、心理问题、互动不足、学习意愿以及对表现反馈的渴望。医学生在在线PAL课程期间报告的主要挑战是网络连接、课程安排和时间方面的基础设施问题。不专业的学习环境、行为问题和性格变化方面的心理问题、与同伴、导师和患者的互动不足、学习意愿以及对表现反馈的渴望是学生面临的其他重要挑战。
我们研究中所探究的这些挑战可供医学教育工作者参考,以便将在线PAL纳入课程中,作为一种有效、高效的替代教学模式,尤其是在当前新冠疫情这样的特殊情况下。