NC State University, Raleigh, North Carolina, USA.
World Bank, Washington, District of Columbia, USA.
BMJ Glob Health. 2021 Oct;6(10). doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2021-006066.
In 2021, many countries have begun distribution of COVID-19 vaccines but are hampered by significant levels of vaccine hesitancy or apathy. Experts recommend that standard health communication campaigns be expanded to include a more holistic approach of behaviourally oriented strategies. We constructed a large-scale Delphi panel of marketing and behavioural science university faculty to assess 12 previously reported US vaccination promotion strategies, asking respondents to assess applicability of the strategy in their country, how efficacy might compare to the USA and recommendations for local adaptations necessary to successful implementation. Separately, we sought to determine whether strategies based on cognitive mechanisms (eg, 'nudges') are more readily generalisable than strategies based on social identity. Ninety-two marketing and behavioural science faculty from universities worldwide participated. Globally, all 12 behavioural strategies were validated; a majority of respondents reported that they would or could work well in their country. While all strategies were strongly validated at a global level, specific need for regional adaptation was identified. Also, open-ended responses suggested the addition of three emergent strategies to a global effort. Finally, we see that strategies based on some types of cognitive mechanisms are more readily generalisable across regions than mechanisms based on social identity, however, this is not always true of 'nudge' strategies. All 12 strategies are robust to global use and consensus exists on adaptation for optimal efficacy in different regions; specific strategy recommendations are posited. Use of these strategies can accelerate individual country efforts to achieve desired vaccination rates to protect global public health.
2021 年,许多国家已开始分发 COVID-19 疫苗,但由于疫苗犹豫或冷漠程度较高而受阻。专家建议扩大标准的卫生宣传运动,纳入更全面的行为导向策略。我们构建了一个大规模的营销和行为科学大学教师德尔菲小组,以评估之前报告的 12 项美国疫苗推广策略,要求受访者评估该策略在其国家/地区的适用性,与美国相比其效果如何,以及成功实施所需的当地调整建议。此外,我们还试图确定基于认知机制(例如“助推”)的策略是否比基于社会认同的策略更容易推广。来自全球大学的 92 名营销和行为科学教师参与了这项研究。在全球范围内,所有 12 项行为策略都得到了验证;大多数受访者表示,他们将或可以在自己的国家/地区很好地实施这些策略。虽然所有策略在全球层面都得到了强烈验证,但也确定了特定的区域适应需求。此外,开放式回复建议在全球努力中增加三种新出现的策略。最后,我们发现基于某些类型认知机制的策略比基于社会认同的机制更容易在不同地区推广,但“助推”策略并非总是如此。所有 12 项策略都可在全球范围内广泛使用,并且在不同地区达到最佳效果的适应方面存在共识;提出了具体的策略建议。这些策略的使用可以加速各个国家实现预期疫苗接种率以保护全球公共卫生的努力。