Lee Liza, Desroches Mireille, Mukhi Shamir, Bancej Christina
Centre for Immunization and Respiratory Infectious Diseases, Public Health Agency of Canada, Ottawa, ON.
National Microbiology Laboratory, Public Health Agency of Canada, Winnipeg, MB.
Can Commun Dis Rep. 2021 Sep 10;47(9):357-363. doi: 10.14745/ccdr.v47i09a02.
Sentinel influenza-like illness (ILI) surveillance is an essential component of a comprehensive influenza surveillance program. Community-based ILI surveillance systems that rely solely on sentinel healthcare practices omit important segments of the population, including those who do not seek medical care. Participatory surveillance, which relies on community participation in surveillance, may address some limitations of traditional ILI systems.
We aimed to evaluate FluWatchers, a crowdsourced ILI application developed to complement and complete ILI surveillance in Canada.
Using established frameworks for surveillance evaluations, we assessed the acceptability, reliability, accuracy and usefulness of the FluWatchers system 2015-2016, through 2018-2019. Evaluation indicators were compared against national surveillance indicators of ILI and of laboratory confirmed respiratory virus infections.
The acceptability of FluWatchers was demonstrated by growth of 50%-100% in season-over-season participation, and a consistent season-over-season retention of 80%. Reliability was greater for FluWatchers than for our traditional ILI system, although both systems had week-over-week fluctuations in the number of participants responding. FluWatchers' ILI rates had moderate correlation with weekly influenza laboratory detection rates and other winter seasonal respiratory virus detections including respiratory syncytial virus and seasonal coronaviruses. Finally, FluWatchers has demonstrated its usefulness as a source of core FluWatch surveillance information and has the potential to fill data gaps in current programs for influenza surveillance and control.
FluWatchers is an example of an innovative digital participatory surveillance program that was created to address limitations of traditional ILI surveillance in Canada. It fulfills the surveillance system evaluation criteria of acceptability, reliability, accuracy and usefulness.
流感样病例(ILI)哨点监测是全面流感监测计划的重要组成部分。仅依靠哨点医疗机构的基于社区的ILI监测系统遗漏了重要的人群部分,包括那些不寻求医疗护理的人。参与式监测依赖于社区参与监测,可能会解决传统ILI系统的一些局限性。
我们旨在评估FluWatchers,这是一款为补充和完善加拿大ILI监测而开发的众包ILI应用程序。
我们使用既定的监测评估框架,在2015 - 2016年至2018 - 2019年期间评估了FluWatchers系统的可接受性、可靠性、准确性和实用性。将评估指标与ILI以及实验室确诊的呼吸道病毒感染的国家监测指标进行比较。
FluWatchers的可接受性体现在季节性参与度增长50% - 100%,以及季节性留存率持续保持在80%。FluWatchers的可靠性高于我们的传统ILI系统,尽管两个系统在每周回复的参与者数量上都有波动。FluWatchers的ILI发病率与每周流感实验室检测率以及其他冬季季节性呼吸道病毒检测(包括呼吸道合胞病毒和季节性冠状病毒)有中度相关性。最后,FluWatchers已证明其作为核心FluWatch监测信息来源的实用性,并且有潜力填补当前流感监测和控制计划中的数据空白。
FluWatchers是一个创新的数字参与式监测计划的例子,旨在解决加拿大传统ILI监测的局限性。它满足了监测系统评估标准中的可接受性、可靠性、准确性和实用性。