Yamada Shigeru, Takiyama Hirotoshi, Isozaki Yuka, Shinoto Makoto, Ebner Daniel K, Koto Masashi, Tsuji Hiroshi, Miyauchi Hideaki, Sekimoto Mitsugu, Ueno Hideki, Itabashi Michio, Ikeda Masataka, Matsubara Hisahiro
QST Hospital, National Institutes for Quantum and Radiological Science and Technology, Chiba, Japan.
Graduate School of Medicine, Chiba University, Chiba, Japan.
Ann Surg Oncol. 2022 Jan;29(1):99-106. doi: 10.1245/s10434-021-10876-4. Epub 2021 Oct 18.
This study aimed to assess the safety and efficacy of carbon-ion radiotherapy (CIRT) for salvage of previously X-ray-irradiated (XRT) locally recurrent rectal cancer (LRRC).
Between September 2005 and December 2017, 77 patients with LRRC were treated with CIRT re-irradiation. All the patients had received prior XRT with a median dose of 50.0 Gy (range 20-74 Gy), principally for neoadjuvant or adjuvant recurrence prophylaxis in 34 patients and for recurrence in 43 patients. The total CIRT dose of 70.4 Gy (RBE) (gray relative biologic effectiveness) was administered in 16 fixed fractions during 4 weeks (4.4 Gy [RBE] per fraction).
All the patients completed the scheduled treatment course. None of the patients received resection after CIRT. Acute grade 3 toxicities occurred for eight patients (10 %), including five grade 3 pelvic infections (2 involving pain and 1 involving neuropathy). Late grade 3 toxicities occurred for 16 patients (21 %): 13 with late grade 3 pelvic infections, 9 with gastrointestinal toxicity, 1 with skin toxicity, 2 with pain, and 4 with neuropathy. No grade 4+ toxicity was noted. The overall local control rates (infield + out-of-field recurrence) were 69 % at 3 years and 62 % at 5 years. In the planning target volume (PTV), the infield recurrence rates were 90 % and 87 % respectively. The control rates for regional recurrence were 85 % at 3 years and 81 % at 5 years. The median overall survival time was 47 months. The survival rates were 61 % at 3 years and 38 % at 5 years.
Carbon-ion re-irradiation of previously X-ray-irradiated locally recurrent rectal cancer appears to be safe and effective, providing good local control and survival advantage without unacceptable morbidity.
本研究旨在评估碳离子放疗(CIRT)对先前接受过X线照射(XRT)的局部复发性直肠癌(LRRC)进行挽救性治疗的安全性和有效性。
2005年9月至2017年12月期间,77例LRRC患者接受了CIRT再照射治疗。所有患者均接受过先前的XRT,中位剂量为50.0 Gy(范围20 - 74 Gy),其中34例主要用于新辅助或辅助性复发预防,43例用于复发治疗。在4周内分16个固定剂量给予总CIRT剂量70.4 Gy(相对生物效应剂量,RBE)(每剂量4.4 Gy [RBE])。
所有患者均完成了预定的治疗疗程。CIRT治疗后无患者接受手术切除。8例患者(10%)出现3级急性毒性反应,包括5例3级盆腔感染(2例伴有疼痛,1例伴有神经病变)。16例患者(21%)出现3级晚期毒性反应:13例晚期3级盆腔感染,9例胃肠道毒性,1例皮肤毒性,2例疼痛,4例神经病变。未观察到4级及以上毒性反应。3年时总体局部控制率(靶区内 + 靶区外复发)为69%,5年时为62%。在计划靶体积(PTV)中,靶区内复发率分别为90%和87%。区域复发控制率3年时为85%,5年时为81%。中位总生存时间为47个月。3年生存率为61%,5年生存率为38%。
对先前接受过X线照射的局部复发性直肠癌进行碳离子再照射似乎是安全有效的,可提供良好的局部控制和生存优势,且无不可接受的发病率。