Palmisano Flaviana, Biagi Federico, Peragine Vito
Department of Economics and Law, Sapienza University of Rome, Via del Castro Laurenziano 9, 00161 Rome, Italy.
JRC European Commission, Ispra, Italy.
Res High Educ. 2022;63(3):514-565. doi: 10.1007/s11162-021-09658-4. Epub 2021 Oct 20.
This study provides comparable lower-bound estimates of inequality of opportunity for tertiary education (EIOp) for 31 countries in Europe, by using the two EU-SILC waves for which information on family background is available (2005 and 2011). The results reveal an important degree of heterogeneity, with Northern European countries showing low levels of inequality of opportunity and Mediterranean and Eastern European countries characterized by significant degrees of unfair educational inequalities. Parental education and occupation are the most relevant circumstances in the great majority of the countries considered. This study also exploits the two point-in-time observations available and analyses the relationship between some country-specific characteristics and inequality of opportunity in tertiary education. The analysis documents a negative association between EIOp and real GDP per capita, possibly indicating that higher equality of opportunity in tertiary education and economic growth are complementary objectives. Two results emerge as especially robust: in all the specifications we find a positive association between EIOp and the students/teacher ratio, and a negative one between EIOp and public spending in tertiary education. While we do not claim that such correlations should be interpreted causally, we think that they might indicate a meaningful underlying relationship between equality of opportunity in tertiary education and the availability of financial and non-financial resources.
本研究利用两轮可获取家庭背景信息的欧盟收入和生活条件调查(2005年和2011年),对欧洲31个国家高等教育机会不平等(EIOp)给出了具有可比性的下限估计。结果显示出重要程度的异质性,北欧国家的机会不平等水平较低,而地中海和东欧国家则存在显著程度的不公平教育不平等。在所考虑的绝大多数国家中,父母的教育程度和职业是最相关的影响因素。本研究还利用了两个时间点的观测数据,分析了一些特定国家特征与高等教育机会不平等之间的关系。分析表明EIOp与人均实际国内生产总值之间存在负相关关系,这可能表明高等教育机会平等程度的提高与经济增长是相辅相成的目标。有两个结果特别稳健:在所有设定中,我们发现EIOp与学生/教师比率之间呈正相关,与高等教育公共支出之间呈负相关。虽然我们并不认为这些相关性应被解释为因果关系,但我们认为它们可能表明高等教育机会平等与财政和非财政资源的可得性之间存在有意义的潜在关系。