Department of Applied Psychology, New York University, New York City, NY, USA.
Bronfenbrenner Center for Translational Research, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA.
J Youth Adolesc. 2022 Mar;51(3):409-427. doi: 10.1007/s10964-021-01527-8. Epub 2021 Oct 27.
Critical consciousness has been linked to a range of positive outcomes, particularly among marginalized youth; yet, evidence on its developmental antecedents remains limited. The current study examines whether arts participation is associated with positive change in critical consciousness, and whether these associations differ by youth's social group status. The sample consisted of high school youth (N = 2537; 10% Latinx, 7% Multiracial; 4% Black; 5% Asian; 72% White; 2% Other; 53% Female; Mage = 15.69; age range = 10-20). The results showed that youth with higher arts participation demonstrate higher growth in critical reflection and action, adjusting for baseline critical consciousness, other types of extracurricular participation, and demographic characteristics. The association between arts participation and critical action was significantly stronger for youth of color than for white youth, and the association between arts participation and critical reflection was marginally significantly stronger for white youth than for youth of color. These findings suggest that it is crucial to extend opportunities for arts involvement to all students, and to expand the ways in which arts involvement can promote critical consciousness for youth of varying dimensions of oppression and privilege.
批判意识与一系列积极的结果相关联,特别是在边缘化的青年中;然而,关于其发展前因的证据仍然有限。本研究考察了艺术参与是否与批判意识的积极变化相关,以及这些关联是否因青年的社会群体地位而异。样本由高中生组成(N=2537;10%拉丁裔,7%多种族;4%黑人;5%亚裔;72%白人;2%其他;53%女性;Mage=15.69;年龄范围=10-20)。结果表明,与基线批判意识、其他类型的课外参与以及人口特征相比,艺术参与度较高的青年在批判反思和行动方面的增长更高。艺术参与和批判行动之间的关联对于有色人种青年比白人青年更强,而艺术参与和批判反思之间的关联对于白人青年比有色人种青年略强。这些发现表明,至关重要的是要向所有学生扩展艺术参与的机会,并扩大艺术参与促进不同压迫和特权维度的青年批判意识的方式。