Aung Si Thu, Wongsawat Yodchanan
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Mahidol University, Phuttamonthon, Nakhon Pathom, Thailand.
PeerJ Comput Sci. 2021 Oct 15;7:e744. doi: 10.7717/peerj-cs.744. eCollection 2021.
Epilepsy is a common neurological disease that affects a wide range of the world population and is not limited by age. Moreover, seizures can occur anytime and anywhere because of the sudden abnormal discharge of brain neurons, leading to malfunction. The seizures of approximately 30% of epilepsy patients cannot be treated with medicines or surgery; hence these patients would benefit from a seizure prediction system to live normal lives. Thus, a system that can predict a seizure before its onset could improve not only these patients' social lives but also their safety. Numerous seizure prediction methods have already been proposed, but the performance measures of these methods are still inadequate for a complete prediction system. Here, a seizure prediction system is proposed by exploring the advantages of multivariate entropy, which can reflect the complexity of multivariate time series over multiple scales (frequencies), called multivariate multiscale modified-distribution entropy (MM-mDistEn), with an artificial neural network (ANN). The phase-space reconstruction and estimation of the probability density between vectors provide hidden complex information. The multivariate time series property of MM-mDistEn provides more understandable information within the multichannel data and makes it possible to predict of epilepsy. Moreover, the proposed method was tested with two different analyses: simulation data analysis proves that the proposed method has strong consistency over the different parameter selections, and the results from experimental data analysis showed that the proposed entropy combined with an ANN obtains performance measures of 98.66% accuracy, 91.82% sensitivity, 99.11% specificity, and 0.84 area under the curve (AUC) value. In addition, the seizure alarm system was applied as a postprocessing step for prediction purposes, and a false alarm rate of 0.014 per hour and an average prediction time of 26.73 min before seizure onset were achieved by the proposed method. Thus, the proposed entropy as a feature extraction method combined with an ANN can predict the ictal state of epilepsy, and the results show great potential for all epilepsy patients.
癫痫是一种常见的神经系统疾病,影响着全球广泛的人群,且不受年龄限制。此外,由于脑神经元突然异常放电导致功能失调,癫痫发作可随时随地发生。约30%的癫痫患者的发作无法通过药物或手术治疗;因此,这些患者将受益于癫痫发作预测系统以过上正常生活。因此,一个能够在癫痫发作前进行预测的系统不仅可以改善这些患者的社交生活,还能提高他们的安全性。已经提出了许多癫痫发作预测方法,但这些方法的性能指标对于一个完整的预测系统来说仍然不够完善。在此,通过探索多变量熵的优势,提出了一种癫痫发作预测系统,多变量熵能够反映多尺度(频率)上多变量时间序列的复杂性,称为多变量多尺度修正分布熵(MM-mDistEn),并结合人工神经网络(ANN)。相空间重构和向量间概率密度估计提供了隐藏的复杂信息。MM-mDistEn的多变量时间序列特性在多通道数据中提供了更易理解的信息,并使得癫痫预测成为可能。此外,该方法通过两种不同的分析进行了测试:模拟数据分析证明该方法在不同参数选择下具有很强的一致性,实验数据分析结果表明,所提出的熵与人工神经网络相结合,获得了98.66%的准确率、91.82%的灵敏度、99.11% 的特异性和0.84的曲线下面积(AUC)值的性能指标。此外,癫痫发作警报系统作为预测目的的后处理步骤被应用,所提出的方法实现了每小时0.014的误报率和癫痫发作前26.73分钟的平均预测时间。因此,所提出的作为特征提取方法的熵与人工神经网络相结合可以预测癫痫的发作状态,结果显示出对所有癫痫患者具有巨大潜力。