Seo Yuna, Jin Chul, Cho Seung-Yeon, Park Seong-Uk, Jung Woo-Sang, Moon Sang-Kwan, Park Jung-Mi, Ko Chang-Nam, Cho Ki-Ho, Kwon Seungwon
Department of Korean Medicine Cardiology and Neurology, Graduate School, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, South Korea.
Department of Cardiology and Neurology, College of Korean Medicine, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, South Korea.
Front Neurol. 2021 Oct 18;12:710769. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2021.710769. eCollection 2021.
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic immune-mediated inflammatory disease of the central nervous system that is gradually increasing in prevalence. The etiology of MS remains unknown; however, it is assumed to be caused by a deterioration of autoimmune regulation. Although immunomodulatory agents are a standard treatment option in patients with MS, there is insufficient evidence about their clinical efficacy in symptomatic treatment, and many MS patients resort to complementary and alternative medicine. For this reason, we conducted a scoping review to investigate the current status of the clinical evidence related to traditional East Asian herbal medicine treatment for MS and to inform future research and treatment strategies. A scoping review is an emerging methodology for knowledge synthesis that adopts the Arksey and O'Malley framework. The research question was, "What has been studied about the herbal medicine treatments administered to patients with MS?" Articles published until 2019 were identified in six databases (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane, KoreaMed, NDSL, and OASIS) in March of 2020. Data from the included studies were charted and descriptively analyzed in relation to the study's research questions. Of the 1,445 articles identified, 14 studies were included in this review. Single and serial case reports constituted the majority (42.86%), with 57.14% of studies conducted in China. A total of 20 prescriptions containing 95 herbs were used in the intervention and observational studies. Herbal medicines were effective at improving clinical symptoms of MS and reducing recurrence frequency. The main cause of MS was presumed to be oxidative stress, which enhances inflammation and, consequently, causes neuronal death. Herbal medicines were determined to improve the symptoms of MS and to reduce the frequency of recurrences. This study suggests that herbal medicines are promising and worth pursuing further studies but the state of current evidence is poor. Thus, further, high-quality studies included larger randomized trial are required.
多发性硬化症(MS)是一种慢性免疫介导的中枢神经系统炎症性疾病,其患病率正在逐渐上升。MS的病因尚不清楚;然而,据推测是由自身免疫调节功能衰退所致。尽管免疫调节药物是MS患者的标准治疗选择,但关于其对症治疗的临床疗效证据不足,许多MS患者求助于补充和替代医学。因此,我们进行了一项范围综述,以调查与东亚传统草药治疗MS相关的临床证据现状,并为未来的研究和治疗策略提供参考。范围综述是一种采用阿克西和奥马利框架的新兴知识综合方法。研究问题是:“关于给予MS患者的草药治疗,有哪些研究?”2020年3月,在六个数据库(PubMed、Embase、Cochrane、KoreaMed、NDSL和OASIS)中检索到截至2019年发表的文章。纳入研究的数据根据研究问题进行图表绘制和描述性分析。在检索到的1445篇文章中,本综述纳入了14项研究。单例和系列病例报告占大多数(42.86%),57.14%的研究在中国进行。干预和观察性研究共使用了20个含有95种草药的方剂。草药对改善MS临床症状和降低复发频率有效。MS的主要病因被认为是氧化应激,氧化应激会加剧炎症,进而导致神经元死亡。已确定草药可改善MS症状并降低复发频率。本研究表明,草药前景广阔,值得进一步研究,但目前的证据状况不佳。因此,需要进一步开展包括大型随机试验在内的高质量研究。