School of Psychology, Bangor University, Bangor, UK.
Economics Department, Universidad de Los Andes, Bogotá, Colombia.
Child Care Health Dev. 2022 Mar;48(2):225-238. doi: 10.1111/cch.12921. Epub 2021 Nov 11.
Integrating early childhood parenting programmes into existing government services is a key strategy for reducing the loss of children's developmental potential in low- and middle-income countries. There is limited evidence of participants' perceptions of these programmes, especially when implemented at scale. We integrated an intervention into an existing government programme targeting pregnant women and mothers of children up to 2 years of age and their families in rural Colombia.
As part of a cluster randomized trial, 171 government workers (facilitators) implemented the intervention. The intervention included four components: (1) structured curricula, (2) play materials, (3) nutrition and (4) training and supervision. In this qualitative evaluation of the programme, we conducted semi-structured interviews with beneficiary mothers (n = 62), facilitators (n = 40) and supervisors (n = 8). Topic guides were developed to collect information on participants' perspectives of the acceptability, feasibility and effectiveness of the intervention and the enablers and barriers to implementation. All interviews were audiotaped and transcribed, and data were analysed using the framework approach.
Participants' responses indicated that the intervention was acceptable, feasible and effective. Key enablers to implementation were (1) the use of evidence-based behaviour change techniques leading to interactive, fun and participatory sessions; (2) structured curricula with easy to use, simple activities and materials; (3) the focus on positive, supportive relationships; and (4) the perceived benefits of the programme to the beneficiary mothers, children and families, facilitators and programme supervisors. The main barriers were (1) facilitators took time to become comfortable and competent in using the new participatory methodology and (2) the logistics related to making and distributing the play materials.
Providing structured curricula and play materials with training and ongoing supervision to enhance an existing programme targeting mothers, families and children was reported as acceptable, feasible and effective by beneficiary mothers and programme staff.
将儿童养育计划纳入现有政府服务是减少中低收入国家儿童发展潜力损失的关键策略。关于这些计划,尤其是在大规模实施时,参与者的看法的证据有限。我们将一项干预措施纳入哥伦比亚农村地区针对孕妇和 2 岁以下儿童及其家庭的现有政府计划中。
作为一项整群随机试验的一部分,171 名政府工作人员(促进者)实施了该干预措施。该干预措施包括四个部分:(1)结构化课程,(2)游戏材料,(3)营养和(4)培训和监督。在对该计划的定性评估中,我们对受益母亲(n=62)、促进者(n=40)和主管(n=8)进行了半结构化访谈。制定了主题指南,以收集参与者对干预措施的可接受性、可行性和有效性以及实施的促成因素和障碍的看法。所有访谈均进行了录音和转录,并使用框架方法进行了数据分析。
参与者的回应表明该干预措施是可接受的、可行的和有效的。实施的关键促成因素包括:(1)使用循证行为改变技术,导致互动、有趣和参与式的课程;(2)结构化课程,使用易于使用、简单的活动和材料;(3)注重积极、支持性的关系;(4)计划对受益母亲、儿童和家庭、促进者和计划主管的感知益处。主要障碍包括:(1)促进者需要时间来适应和熟练使用新的参与式方法;(2)制作和分发游戏材料的后勤工作。
为现有针对母亲、家庭和儿童的计划提供结构化课程和游戏材料,并提供培训和持续监督,据受益母亲和计划工作人员称,该方法是可接受的、可行的和有效的。