Gautam Rupali, Mohan Harsh, Handa Uma, Bisht Bhumika
Indian Medical Association Blood Bank, Gandhidham, Kutch, Gujarat 370201, India.
Oncquest Laboratories, Paras Hospitals, Panchkula, Haryana, India.
Sarcoma. 2021 Oct 29;2021:6633646. doi: 10.1155/2021/6633646. eCollection 2021.
Intraoperative pathologic consultation plays an essential role in therapeutic decision making, possibly avoiding under or overtreatment of the patient. Common indications for intraoperative consultation include obtaining a diagnosis in an unknown pathology, ruling out malignancy, confirming a provisional diagnosis, and assessing margin status. Fifty patients undergoing surgery for soft tissue tumors or tumor-like lesions were included in the present prospective study to evaluate the role of intraoperative pathologic consultation by imprint and scrape cytology. Careful and quick gross examination of the specimen was performed, followed by processing for imprint and scrape smears. The prepared smears were evaluated by three pathologists and the cytological diagnosis compared subsequently with final histopathological diagnosis. Intraoperative consultation was primarily requested to make or confirm preoperative diagnosis. In 44.0% cases, no previous tissue/cytological diagnosis was available. In 56.0% cases, previous pathological diagnosis was available, but the reports were inconclusive or were reported from outside our institute. The diagnostic yield of imprint smears was 24% (5 malignant, 6 benign, and 1 inconclusive), and scrape smears was 100% (10 malignant, 38 benign, and 2 inconclusive). Paraffin-embedded sections yielded diagnosis in 100% cases (11 malignant, 38 benign, and 1 nonneoplastic). Imprint smears alone were not of much help in intraoperative diagnosis. Scrape smears were found to be superior to imprint smears in terms of diagnostic yield and accuracy. Combined imprint and scrape smear cytology did not provide any advantage in intraoperative provisional tissue diagnosis in soft tissue tumors.
术中病理会诊在治疗决策中起着至关重要的作用,可能避免患者治疗不足或过度治疗。术中会诊的常见指征包括对未知病理进行诊断、排除恶性肿瘤、确认初步诊断以及评估切缘状态。本前瞻性研究纳入了50例接受软组织肿瘤或肿瘤样病变手术的患者,以评估印片和刮片细胞学在术中病理会诊中的作用。对标本进行仔细快速的大体检查,随后进行印片和刮片涂片处理。三位病理学家对制备好的涂片进行评估,随后将细胞学诊断与最终组织病理学诊断进行比较。术中会诊主要用于做出或确认术前诊断。在44.0%的病例中,之前没有组织/细胞学诊断。在56.0%的病例中,有之前的病理诊断,但报告不确定或来自本机构以外。印片涂片的诊断阳性率为24%(5例恶性、6例良性和1例不确定),刮片涂片为100%(10例恶性、38例良性和2例不确定)。石蜡包埋切片在100%的病例中得出诊断结果(11例恶性、38例良性和1例非肿瘤性)。仅印片涂片在术中诊断中帮助不大。发现刮片涂片在诊断阳性率和准确性方面优于印片涂片。联合印片和刮片涂片细胞学在软组织肿瘤的术中临时组织诊断中没有提供任何优势。