Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Nanyang Technological University, 11 Mandalay Road, Singapore, Singapore.
Department of Primary Care and Public Health, School of Public Health, Imperial College London, London, UK.
BMC Fam Pract. 2021 Nov 16;22(1):229. doi: 10.1186/s12875-021-01570-1.
A shortage of primary care physicians has been reported in many countries. Primary care systems are diverse and the challenges leading to a decline in workforce are at times context-specific and require tailored solutions. Inviting frontline clinicians to share their insights can help identify optimal strategies for a particular setting. To determine priorities for family physicians' and general practitioners' recruitment and retention in Singapore, we invited primary care physicians to rank pertinent strategies using PRIORITIZE, a transparent, systematic priority-setting approach.
The study advisory board, consisting of representatives of Singapore's key primary care stakeholders, determined the criteria for prioritising of general practitioners (GPs) and family physicians (FPs) recruitment and retention strategies in Singapore. A comprehensive list of GPs and FPs recruitment and retention strategies was extracted from a recent systematic review of the relevant literature. A questionnaire listing the strategies and the scoring criteria was administered online to doctors practicing in public and private sector in Singapore. Respondents' scores were combined to create a ranked list of locally most relevant strategies for improving GPs and FPs recruitment and retention.
We recruited a diverse sample of 50 GPs and FPs practicing in a variety of primary care settings, many with a range of additional professional responsibilities. Around 60 and 66% of respondents thought that there was a problem with recruitment and retention of GPs and FPs in Singapore, respectively. Strategies focusing on promoting primary care by emphasizing the advantages and enhancing the status of the profession as well as training-related strategies, such as sub-specialisation and high-quality rotations were considered priorities for improving recruitment. For retention of GPs and FPs, improving working conditions by increasing GPs' and FPs' salary and recognition, as well as varying or reducing time commitment, were seen as the most important strategies. The ranking between physicians working in public and private sector was mostly similar, with nine out of the top ten recruitment and retention strategies being the same.
Primary care physicians' ranking of recruitment and retention strategies for GPs and FPs in Singapore provide important insight into the challenges and the solutions as seen by the members of the profession themselves. This information can guide future policy and decision making in this area.
许多国家都报告称初级保健医生短缺。初级保健系统多种多样,导致劳动力减少的挑战有时具有特定背景,需要针对性的解决方案。邀请一线临床医生分享他们的见解有助于确定特定环境下的最佳策略。为了确定在新加坡招聘和留住家庭医生和全科医生的优先事项,我们邀请初级保健医生使用 PRIORITIZE 对相关策略进行排名,这是一种透明、系统的优先排序方法。
由新加坡主要初级保健利益相关者的代表组成的研究顾问委员会确定了在新加坡优先考虑全科医生 (GP) 和家庭医生 (FP) 招聘和留用策略的标准。从最近对相关文献的系统综述中提取了全科医生和家庭医生招聘和留用策略的综合清单。一份列出策略和评分标准的问卷在线分发给在新加坡公共和私营部门执业的医生。将受访者的分数合并为一个排名列表,列出了改善 GP 和 FP 招聘和留用的本地最相关策略。
我们招募了来自各种初级保健环境的 50 名 GP 和 FP,他们的专业背景多样,许多人还承担着一系列额外的专业职责。大约 60%和 66%的受访者认为新加坡 GP 和 FP 的招聘和留用存在问题。强调初级保健的优势、提高职业地位以及培训相关策略(如专科化和高质量轮转)的策略被认为是改善招聘的优先事项。对于 GP 和 FP 的留用,提高 GP 和 FP 的工资和认可度、改变或减少时间承诺等改善工作条件的策略被视为最重要的策略。在公共部门和私营部门工作的医生之间的排名大多相似,前 10 名招聘和留用策略中有 9 项是相同的。
新加坡初级保健医生对 GP 和 FP 招聘和留用策略的排名为该专业人员本身所看到的挑战和解决方案提供了重要的见解。这些信息可以为该领域的未来政策和决策提供指导。