Mencel Joanna, Jaskólska Anna, Marusiak Jaroslaw, Kisiel-Sajewicz Katarzyna, Siemiatycka Magdalena, Kaminski Lukasz, Jaskólski Artur
Department of Kinesiology, Wroclaw University of Health and Sport Sciences, Poland, Wroclaw, Poland.
PeerJ. 2021 Nov 10;9:e12367. doi: 10.7717/peerj.12367. eCollection 2021.
The aim of the study was to compare the mechanical properties of three human skeletal muscles: biceps brachii (BB), rectus femoris (RF), and tibialis anterior (TA) at rest measured by myoton device in males ( = 16, mean age 21.2 ± 0.6 years) and females ( = 16; 21.2 ± 0.9 years) and to investigate the influence of skin and subcutaneous tissue thickness (skinfold thickness, SFT) and gender on myometric parameters of the three skeletal muscles.
We measured the following mechanical and viscoelastic muscle properties using MyotonPRO: frequency (F [Hz]), decrement (D [log]), stiffness (S [N/m]), relaxation time (R [ms]) and creepability (C [De]). The values of SFT for all selected muscles were assessed by caliper. A mixed-design analysis of variance with gender as between subject comparison was used for assessing the differences between gender and muscles in SFT and each of the myometric parameters separately (F, D, S, R and C). Pearson correlation coefficient or Spearman's rank correlation coefficient between SFT and myometric parameters was conducted for males, females and males and females together. The level of statistical significance was set at α ≤ 0.05 with Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons.
The SFT over the RF, TA, and BB muscles in women was statistically significantly larger compared with that of males. In females and males, the SFT over the RF was larger than over the TA and BB, and the SFT over the TA was larger compared with over the BB. The values of F and S recorded for the TA muscle were the highest among the three muscles, while D, C, and R were lowest in TA but highest in the RF muscle in men and women. The values of F and S were smaller in females than in males. Gender comparison of D, C, and R values showed that only D for the RF was significantly lower in females than in males, and C for the RF and TA was significantly larger in females than in males. Some correlation between SFT and myometric parameters were different between males and females. For example, there was a significant, negative correlation between SFT and F for all muscles in females, and a significant, positive correlation between these parameters for BB and TA (not for RF) in males. For pooled data (males and females together), a negative significant correlation between SFT and F was observed for RF and TA (not significant for BB muscle).
It is concluded that the TA compared with the BB and RF has significantly greater F and S but the smallest D and C and the shortest R. Gender and muscle differences in the SFT may affect the measurements of muscle properties using MyotonPRO. The relationship between SFT and myometric parameters is different in males and females in the RF, TA, and BB muscles. Therefore, the myometric data should be analyzed in males and females separately.
本研究旨在比较通过肌张力测量仪在男性(n = 16,平均年龄21.2±0.6岁)和女性(n = 16;21.2±0.9岁)静息状态下测量的肱二头肌(BB)、股直肌(RF)和胫骨前肌(TA)这三块人体骨骼肌的力学性能,并研究皮肤和皮下组织厚度(皮褶厚度,SFT)及性别对这三块骨骼肌肌力测量参数的影响。
我们使用MyotonPRO测量了以下肌肉的力学和粘弹性特性:频率(F [Hz])、衰减(D [log])、刚度(S [N/m])、松弛时间(R [ms])和蠕变性(C [De])。所有选定肌肉的SFT值通过卡尺进行评估。采用以性别作为组间比较的混合设计方差分析,分别评估性别和肌肉在SFT以及每个肌力测量参数(F、D、S、R和C)方面的差异。对男性、女性以及男性和女性合并数据分别进行SFT与肌力测量参数之间的Pearson相关系数或Spearman等级相关系数分析。统计学显著性水平设定为α≤0.05,并采用Bonferroni校正进行多重比较。
女性RF、TA和BB肌肉上的SFT在统计学上显著大于男性。在女性和男性中,RF肌肉上的SFT大于TA和BB肌肉上的,TA肌肉上的SFT大于BB肌肉上的。在这三块肌肉中,TA肌肉记录的F和S值最高,而D、C和R值在TA肌肉中最低,但在男性和女性的RF肌肉中最高。女性的F和S值小于男性。D、C和R值的性别比较显示,仅RF肌肉的D值女性显著低于男性,RF和TA肌肉的C值女性显著大于男性。SFT与肌力测量参数之间的一些相关性在男性和女性之间有所不同。例如,女性所有肌肉的SFT与F之间存在显著负相关,而男性BB和TA(RF除外)的这些参数之间存在显著正相关。对于合并数据(男性和女性一起),RF和TA的SFT与F之间观察到显著负相关(BB肌肉不显著)。
得出的结论是,与BB和RF相比,TA具有显著更高的F和S,但D和C最小,R最短。SFT的性别和肌肉差异可能会影响使用MyotonPRO对肌肉特性的测量。RF、TA和BB肌肉中,SFT与肌力测量参数之间的关系在男性和女性中有所不同。因此,肌力测量数据应分别在男性和女性中进行分析。