Lee Kyeongjin
Department of Physical Therapy, College of Health Science, Kyungdong University, Wonju 24764, Korea.
Healthcare (Basel). 2021 Nov 20;9(11):1591. doi: 10.3390/healthcare9111591.
The global pandemic of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has highlighted the need for remote healthcare services. This study aimed to evaluate the concurrent validity and reliability of tele-assessment using 3D motion analysis and video conferencing applications. The subjects of this study were 14 Pilates instructors and 14 healthy adults, who repeated five exercises of "side spine stretch", "bridge", "toe taps", "quadruped leg raise", and "cat and cow" five times each. We performed 3D kinematic analysis with 16 infrared cameras while the subject performed each exercise, and the image captured by one webcam was transmitted to the evaluators through a video conferencing application, and eight raters evaluated the mobility, stability, and symmetry of the movement. The result was then compared with the gold standard 3D motion analysis to evaluate the teleassessment system. The concurrent validity of the data obtained using both methods was analyzed. In addition, the inter-rater reliability of the data from the eight raters was evaluated. As a result, mobility showed excellent (ICC > 0.75, ICCs: intraclass correlation coefficients) or good agreement (ICC = 0.6-0.74) with 3D motion analysis and tele-assessment in all motions. The analysis of stability showed high agreement in general, but it was not significant in "cat and cow." Symmetry showed moderate agreement only in "bridge" and "toe taps", showing low agreement compared to other components. In addition, the inter-rater reliability of the tele-assessment showed good agreement (ICC = 0.744). Although there were few components with weaker agreements, the results of this study confirmed that it is a valid and reliable method of tele-assessment using video conferencing applications and showed feasibility as an alternative to the existing face-to-face examination.
2019年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)的全球大流行凸显了远程医疗服务的必要性。本研究旨在评估使用3D运动分析和视频会议应用程序进行远程评估的同时效度和信度。本研究的受试者为14名普拉提教练和14名健康成年人,他们将“侧脊柱伸展”“桥”“脚尖轻拍”“四足抬腿”和“猫牛式”这五项练习各重复进行五次。受试者进行每项练习时,我们使用16台红外摄像机进行3D运动学分析,由一个网络摄像头拍摄的图像通过视频会议应用程序传输给评估者,八名评估者对动作的灵活性、稳定性和对称性进行评估。然后将结果与金标准3D运动分析进行比较,以评估远程评估系统。分析了使用两种方法获得的数据的同时效度。此外,还评估了八名评估者数据的评分者间信度。结果显示,在所有动作中,灵活性与3D运动分析和远程评估均表现出极佳的一致性(组内相关系数ICC>0.75)或良好的一致性(ICC=0.6 - 0.74)。稳定性分析总体显示出高度一致性,但在“猫牛式”中不显著。对称性仅在“桥”和“脚尖轻拍”中表现出中等一致性,与其他部分相比一致性较低。此外,远程评估的评分者间信度显示出良好的一致性(ICC = 0.744)。尽管一致性较弱的部分较少,但本研究结果证实,使用视频会议应用程序进行远程评估是一种有效且可靠的方法,并显示出作为现有面对面检查替代方法的可行性。