Kowalska Andrea, Sokolowski Jerzy, Gozdek Tomasz, Krasowski Michał, Kopacz Karolina, Bociong Kinga
Department of General Dentistry, Medical University of Lodz, 92-213 Lodz, Poland.
Institute of Polymer & Dye Technology, Lodz University of Technology, Stefanowskiego 12/16, 90-924 Lodz, Poland.
Polymers (Basel). 2021 Nov 17;13(22):3972. doi: 10.3390/polym13223972.
The aim of this article was to compare the biomechanical properties of commercial composites containing different photoinitiators: Filtek Ultimate (3M ESPE) containing camphorquinone (CQ); Estelite Σ Quick (Tokuyama Dental) with CQ in RAP Technology; Tetric EvoCeram Bleach BLXL (Ivoclar Vivadent AG) with CQ and Lucirin TPO; and Tetric Evoceram Powerfill IVB (Ivoclar Vivadent AG) with CQ and Ivocerin TPO. All samples were cured with a polywave Valo Lamp (Ultradent Products Inc.) with 1450 mW/cm. The microhardness, hardness by Vicker's method, diametral tensile strength, flexural strength and contraction stress with photoelastic analysis were tested. The highest hardness and microhardness were observed for Filtek Ultimate (93.82 ± 17.44 HV), but other composites also displayed sufficient values (from 52 ± 3.92 to 58,82 ± 7.33 HV). Filtek Ultimate not only demonstrated the highest DTS (48.03 ± 5.97 MPa) and FS (87.32 ± 19.03 MPa) but also the highest contraction stress (13.7 ± 0.4 MPa) during polymerization. The TetricEvoCeram Powerfill has optimal microhardness (54.27 ± 4.1 HV), DTS (32.5 ± 5.29 MPa) and FS (79.3 ± 14.37 MPa) and the lowest contraction stress (7.4 ± 1 MPa) during photopolymerization. To summarize, Filtek Ultimate demonstrated the highest microhardness, FS and DTS values; however, composites with additional photoinitiators such as Lucirin TPO and Ivocerin have the lowest polymerization shrinkage. These composites also have higher FS and DTS and microhardness than material containing CQ in Rap Technology.
含有樟脑醌(CQ)的Filtek Ultimate(3M ESPE);采用RAP技术且含有CQ的Estelite Σ Quick(德山齿科);含有CQ和Lucirin TPO的Tetric EvoCeram Bleach BLXL(义获嘉伟瓦登特股份公司);以及含有CQ和Ivocerin TPO的Tetric Evoceram Powerfill IVB(义获嘉伟瓦登特股份公司)。所有样品均使用功率为1450 mW/cm的聚波Valo灯(Ultradent Products Inc.)进行固化。测试了显微硬度、维氏硬度、径向拉伸强度、弯曲强度以及光弹性分析下的收缩应力。Filtek Ultimate的硬度和显微硬度最高(93.82 ± 17.44 HV),但其他复合材料也显示出足够的值(从52 ± 3.92到58.82 ± 7.33 HV)。Filtek Ultimate不仅表现出最高的径向拉伸强度(DTS,48.03 ± 5.97 MPa)和弯曲强度(FS,87.32 ± 19.03 MPa),而且在聚合过程中收缩应力最高(13.7 ± 0.4 MPa)。TetricEvoCeram Powerfill在光聚合过程中具有最佳的显微硬度(54.27 ± 4.1 HV)、径向拉伸强度(32.5 ± 5.29 MPa)和弯曲强度(79.3 ± 14.37 MPa)以及最低的收缩应力(7.4 ± 1 MPa)。总之,Filtek Ultimate的显微硬度、弯曲强度和径向拉伸强度值最高;然而,含有额外光引发剂如Lucirin TPO和Ivocerin的复合材料聚合收缩率最低。这些复合材料的弯曲强度、径向拉伸强度和显微硬度也高于采用RAP技术且含有CQ的材料。