Saavedra Edgar, Mascaraque Laura, Calderon Gonzalo, Del Campo Guillermo, Santamaria Asuncion
CeDInt-UPM, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Campus de Montegancedo, Pozuelo de Alarcón, 28223 Madrid, Spain.
Sensors (Basel). 2021 Nov 9;21(22):7433. doi: 10.3390/s21227433.
Most smart meters are connected and powered by the electric mains, requiring the service interruption and qualified personnel for their installation. Wireless technologies and energy harvesting techniques have been proved as alternatives for communications and power supply, respectively. In this work, we analyse the energy consumption of the most used IoT wireless technologies nowadays: Sigfox, LoRaWAN, NB-IoT, Wi-Fi, BLE. Smart meters' energy consumption accounts for metering, standby and communication processes. Experimental measurements show that communication consumption may vary upon the specific characteristics of each wireless communication technology-payload, connection establishment, transmission time. Results show that the selection of a specific technology will depend on the application requirements (message payload, metering period) and location constraints (communication range, infrastructure availability). Besides, we compare the performance of the most suitable energy harvesting (EH) techniques for smart meters: photovoltaic (PV), radiofrequency (RF) and magnetic induction (MIEH). Thus, EH technique selection will depend on the availability of each source at the smart meter's location. The most appropriate combination of IoT wireless technology and EH technique must be selected accordingly to the very use case requirements and constraints.
大多数智能电表由市电连接并供电,安装时需要中断服务并由专业人员进行操作。无线技术和能量收集技术已分别被证明可作为通信和电源的替代方案。在这项工作中,我们分析了当今最常用的物联网无线技术的能耗:Sigfox、LoRaWAN、窄带物联网(NB-IoT)、Wi-Fi、蓝牙低功耗(BLE)。智能电表的能耗包括计量、待机和通信过程。实验测量表明,通信能耗可能会因每种无线通信技术的特定特性(有效载荷、连接建立、传输时间)而有所不同。结果表明,特定技术的选择将取决于应用需求(消息有效载荷、计量周期)和位置限制(通信范围、基础设施可用性)。此外,我们比较了最适合智能电表的能量收集(EH)技术的性能:光伏(PV)、射频(RF)和磁感应(MIEH)。因此,EH技术的选择将取决于智能电表所在位置每种能源的可用性。必须根据具体用例的要求和限制,相应地选择物联网无线技术和EH技术的最合适组合。