LAMC, Université libre de Bruxelles - Campus du Solbosch, Bruxelles, Belgium.
Ecole de Santé Publique, Université Libre de Bruxelles - Campus Erasme, Bruxelles, Belgium.
Anthropol Med. 2022 Sep;29(3):237-254. doi: 10.1080/13648470.2021.1994332. Epub 2021 Nov 29.
Growing numbers of women are showing interest in clitoral reconstructive surgery after 'Female Genital Mutilation'. The safety and success of reconstructive surgery, however, has not clearly been established and due to lack of evidence the World Health Organization does not recommend it. Based on anthropological research among patients who requested surgery at the Brussels specialist clinic between 2017 and 2020, this paper looks at two cases of women who actually enjoy sex and experience pleasure but request the procedure to become 'whole again' after stigmatising experiences with health-care professionals, sexual partners or gossip among African migrant communities. An ethnographic approach was used including indepth interviews and participant observation during reception appointments, gynecological consultations, sexology and psychotherapy sessions. Despite limited evidence on the safety of the surgical intervention, surgery is often perceived as the ultimate remedy for the 'missing' clitoris. Such beliefs are nourished by predominant discourses of cut women as 'sexually mutilated'. Following Butler, this article elicits how discursive practices on the physiological sex of a woman can shape her gender identity as a complete or incomplete person. We also examine what it was that changed the patients' mind about the surgery in the process of re-building their confidence through sexology therapy and psychotherapy.
越来越多的女性对“女性生殖器切割”后进行阴蒂重建手术表现出兴趣。然而,重建手术的安全性和成功率尚未明确确立,由于缺乏证据,世界卫生组织不建议进行此类手术。基于 2017 年至 2020 年间在布鲁塞尔专科诊所要求手术的患者的人类学研究,本文探讨了两位实际上享受性和体验性愉悦但在与医疗保健专业人员、性伴侣或非洲移民社区的八卦有污名化经历后要求进行手术以恢复“完整”的女性的案例。采用了人种学方法,包括在接待预约、妇科咨询、性学和心理治疗期间进行深入访谈和参与观察。尽管手术干预的安全性证据有限,但手术通常被视为“缺失”阴蒂的最终补救措施。这些信念是由被切割女性作为“性残缺”的主导话语滋养的。本文遵循巴特勒的观点,探讨了关于女性生理性别性别身份的话语实践如何塑造其作为完整或不完整的人的性别认同。我们还研究了在通过性学治疗和心理治疗重建信心的过程中,是什么改变了患者对手术的看法。