Adler Eli, Hebel-Sela Shira, Leshem Oded Adomi, Levy Jonathan, Halperin Eran
Department of Psychology, Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel.
Department of Neuroscience and Biomedical Engineering, Aalto University, Finland.
Int J Intercult Relat. 2022 Jan;86:109-121. doi: 10.1016/j.ijintrel.2021.11.006. Epub 2021 Nov 30.
Previous studies have shown that external threats, such as financial crises and natural disasters, might fuel negative attitudes, emotions, and behaviors towards outgroup members. However, it is unclear what types of outgroups are likely to be targeted when an external threat is taking its toll. In this study, we examine two types of outgroups that might be at risk of becoming victims of intergroup hostility. The first is the "ultimate scapegoat" outgroup which has a long history of negative relations with the ingroup. The second is the "context-dependent" outgroup which is viewed as an outgroup only in certain contexts. We utilized the COVID-19 crisis and the highly diverse social makeup of Israeli society to explore the extent to which each type of outgroup would be targeted. Results from our study ( = 664), conducted during the first peak of COVID-19 in Israel, show that higher levels of exposure to COVID-19 predicted lower willingness to aid outgroups and that outgroup dehumanization mediated this association. However, this held true only when the target outgroup was a context-dependent outgroup. When the target group was the ultimate scapegoat, exposure to COVID-19 did not predict ingroup willingness to aid them. Our findings contribute to our theoretical and practical knowledge on how intergroup hostility proliferates during external threats and, as such, are valuable to scholars, practitioners, and policymakers working to reduce intergroup tensions during large-scale crises.
先前的研究表明,诸如金融危机和自然灾害等外部威胁,可能会助长对外群体成员的负面态度、情绪和行为。然而,当外部威胁造成损害时,哪些类型的外群体可能成为攻击目标尚不清楚。在本研究中,我们考察了两类可能成为群体间敌意受害者的外群体。第一类是“终极替罪羊”外群体,它与内群体长期存在负面关系。第二类是“情境依赖型”外群体,它仅在某些情境下被视为外群体。我们利用新冠疫情危机以及以色列社会高度多样化的社会构成,来探究每种类型的外群体会在多大程度上成为攻击目标。我们在以色列新冠疫情第一个高峰期开展的研究(样本量 = 664)结果显示,接触新冠疫情的程度越高,对内群体援助外群体的意愿就越低,并且对外群体的非人化介导了这种关联。然而,这仅在目标外群体是情境依赖型外群体时成立。当目标群体是终极替罪羊时,接触新冠疫情并不能预测内群体援助他们的意愿。我们的研究结果有助于丰富我们关于外部威胁期间群体间敌意如何扩散的理论和实践知识,因此,对于致力于在大规模危机期间减少群体间紧张关系的学者、从业者和政策制定者而言具有重要价值。