Routine In-Hospital Radiographs Following Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion Surgery: Neither Necessary nor Cost-Effective?

Background Despite a paucity of evidence or literature to support routine in-hospital post-operative radiographs (POXR) of anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) surgery, it remains accepted practice. Most spinal surgeons consider it part of their standard post-operative routine for ACDF despite nearly always documenting a 'satisfactory intra-operative image' at the end of the operation. With an increasing financial pressure on NHS resources, our investigations should be clinically justified and evidence-based. Purpose To evaluate whether a post-operative radiograph of the cervical spine before discharge is either clinically justified or cost-effective in patients who have undergone an ACDF, despite having satisfactory intra-operative imaging. Design A retrospective review of 101 consecutive ACDF patients of radiographs performed before discharge, associated length of inpatient stay, and any complications involved. Methods A retrospective review was performed of 101 ACDF patients who had single or multi-level instrumentation for degenerative spinal disease from a single neurosurgical centre from all surgeons. Seventy-eight had an in-hospital post-operative anteroposterior (AP) and lateral radiograph, 23 did not. In 95 of these, it was documented that there was 'satisfactory intra-operative imaging' before the closure of skin, six lacked documentation of this. All patients had intra-operative imaging of completed instrumentation on the radiology system. Any post-operative complications were noted, and the length of hospital stay (LOS) was recorded. Six patients underwent ACDF following trauma, therefore leaving 95 elective cases. Study parameters also included: number of levels operated on, whether or not a plate was used with a cage, hospital costings for 2-view imaging and additional days of inpatient stay.  Results There was one out of our 101 patients where the post-operative radiograph confirmed unsatisfactory placement of metalwork and warranted a return to surgery. However, the decision to perform this x-ray was based purely on the deteriorating post-operative clinical picture. In the cohort that had POXR's, the average length of stay was 66.7 hours. Without POXR, it was 21 hours. The additional cost to the trust of performing the in-hospital radiographs was calculated to be £71,523 per year. Conclusion In patients who undergo ACDF surgery with an uneventful post-operative course and have satisfactory intra-operative imaging, in-hospital post-operative radiographs serve no clinical purpose and delay discharge. This gives additional cost to the trust, unnecessary radiation exposure and occupies potential bedspace.